Showing posts with label abuse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label abuse. Show all posts

Sunday, February 8, 2015

On when it's enough

This year’s Australian of the Year award recipient was Rosie Batty, a woman who has helped raise the attention we give to domestic violence in our society. This got me thinking a lot about the issue, and in fact it drove me to watch a TED talk on domestic violence by Leslie Morgan Steiner, herself a domestic violence survivor. I strongly recommend you watch it if you haven’t already. What it did for me is it helped me answer - and ask - some questions I hadn't even thought about before. Leslie found herself in love with a man who was charming and wonderful and worshiped her. This was the same man who later beat her several times a week. The questions domestic violence pose to me are 1) how does it happen, how does an intimate relationship become abusive? And 2) why do people stay in those relationships?

You know, I realised something recently and that is that a lot of us don’t know much about domestic violence. In Leslie Morgan Steiner’s talk she pointed out that this was true of her situation – and she didn’t realise that there are warning signs and patterns to the abuse. She speaks of one of the things her ex-partner did from the start of the relationship, and that is to make her believe that she – not he – was the dominant partner in the relationship. You know the type, “he wouldn’t hurt a fly”. In fact, he’d been the victim of physical abuse as a child, he told her. He made it clear that she, not him, was the strong one. I think this is an interesting point for another reason too, and that’s because one thing I remember learning a little while ago is that victims of childhood abuse (be it sexual, psychological, or physical) are predisposed to becoming either abusers themselves or the victims of abuse again – and usually this will be with their intimate partner. 

The second step to coming to be in a domestically violent relationship is to “isolate the victim”. Now this is another interesting one because it can come in the shape of being so in love that you want to spend every minute of every day with your partner, of wanting them all to yourself; but then becomes obsessive in wanting to increasingly (it’s always in small increments) dictate exactly who you speak to, what you wear, who is allowed to be your friend, where and how you can work and live, etc. It’s easy to disguise a controlling nature in the guise of “it’s because I love you so much and I am trying to protect you” or “it’s for your own good”.

Then comes the part where they test you out. Subtle threats. Small violations. Then an apology, of course. There’s always a reason why it happened, and they love you, and they promise it won’t happen again… Then increasingly bigger violations. Most of us have seen the pictures of the “cycle of violence” that occurs in domestic violence situations: violent episode, followed by the remorse, pursuit, and honeymoon phases… until the tension builds up again and culminates in a another violent episode – and the cycle keeps repeating.

Figure 1. The cycle of violence – commonly used to explain the perpetuation of IPV (adapted from Walker, 1979)
In case you haven't seen it. www.psychology.org.au/publications/inpsych/2011/feb/weiss/

One very powerful point that Leslie Morgan Steiner makes in her talk is this: “Why did I stay? The answer is easy. I didn't know he was abusing me”. But surely she must have known, right? Surely people know when they are being physically, emotionally, financially, or sexually abused by their intimate partner, right? Not necessarily, because of the often gradual nature of how abuse escalates. You know what this made me think of? The little cartoon in that Al Gore documentary where the frog who goes from room temperature into boiling water immediately realised the threat and jumps out of the pot, but the frog placed in water at room temperature and then the heat is gradually increased will stay calmly and passively until the water boils him to death.

Leslie Morgan Steiner gave a second interesting reason of why she stayed in an abusive relationship: because she believed she could help her abuser. She loved him. She knew him. She understood him better than anyone else. She knew he was a good person who was just troubled. I mean, shouldn't good people who love each other be self-sacrificing and help each other out? Isn't this particularly more applicable if the abusive partner has a mental illness or a troubled past or is “going through a rough patch”? Shouldn't we stick by them at all costs? Shouldn't we keep giving them another chance? (to repeat the cycle?)...  However, there is a flaw in this logic because it puts a greater emphasis on one person’s satisfaction and happiness at the expense of the happiness and right to be free from abuse of the other partner.

Of course, the final reason people stay in abusive relationships is because they know how dangerous their abusive partner is. Indeed, another thing I learnt from the TED talk is that the period after a relationship has ended is when the threat is greatest for those who have left their abuser. The abuser now has nothing to lose, they are both enraged and empowered. And often they do act with disastrous consequences. This is when we as a society need to step up and stop asking questions like “why doesn't she leave?” in the tone of “well, it’s her fault for staying”, and instead make sure we are educating people to recognise and avoid these situations, and protect victims of abuse from further harm through adequate judicial systems.

Now, one last question I want to go back to is does the fact that the abuser was perhaps affected by mental illness, was “going through a rough patch”, or had a childhood that was prejudicial and unfair excuse the damage they inflict on their partner? Does it make the bruises any lighter? Does it make the torment any easier to bear? Does it make the children, like Rosie Batty's son, who get caught in the path of an abusive relationship any less dead? No. There has to come a time for a victim of domestic violence to realise and acknowledge that they have at least an equal worth to the person whose abuse they continue to tolerate. For some victims it is one final beating that nearly kills them that makes them ‘snap out of their denial’. Denial of the fact that no amount of love will make the relationship good again. That no amount of wishful thinking will make the other partner be nice to you again. That if nothing changes, nothing changes. That you, in fact, are worthy of better than to suffer or die (physically or emotionally) at the hands of someone who you have given your all to. We have to be careful that when we're looking for reasons for why domestic violence happens, that they don't become excuses. We have to focus on prevention before it happens; and support and adequate protection when it's already established.

Sunday, February 17, 2013

On responsibility


I remember one of the greatest lessons taught to me both at home and at school was about responsibility. It was such a good trait in a person that even if you owned up to wrong-doing, there would be an incentive for the admission (e.g. reduced punishment). I wonder now what happened to make taking responsibility for almost anything such a dirty affair.

Do you know when people are quick to claim responsibility for things? When things go right! Politicians, for example, are a great at speaking of their triumphs in war, claiming they achieved this or that target. For a moment it would be possible to convince yourself that Barack Obama was literally holding the firearm that killed Osama bin Laden, such was the claim that “we got him”. In science journals a string of names appear as the “researchers”, and if the discovery or finding is big news enough, the person giving the interview will be the person who runs the research institute or the head of the lab – not the little guy who actually did all the intellectual and physical work. Similarly in medicine, especially in teaching hospitals, the name of the consultant will always be quoted as the guy who did the surgery or who treated a patient’s complex medical problems – where in reality the consultant probably has never laid eyes on the patient. But I am, of course, talking about when things go right, the successes. The culture extends all the way to clinical records, as I have had to explain to patients in the past:  “I know the information is about you, and it was collected and written by me, but it belongs neither to you or me apparently but to the person who lent me the pen and paper (or computer) with which I recorded the information”. Or at least this is what I have been told in the past by previous employers… Imagine if the same had been done to the great poets and writers of the past. Mark Twain would not have made a cent from the proceeds of the sale of Huckleberry Finn but the manufacturer of the pen and paper he wrote with would have made some very easy money!

Now, when things go wrong in medicine, it’s not the hospital’s or the clinic’s fault, it’s not the consultant’s fault – then it is all about the little guy. When competitions are won, a whole nation claims victory; but when they are lost, it’s the one competitor or team who is the loser. When corruption is uncovered, it is always said it was just one person’s fault, not the institution or the culture that drove him to it, etc. We have become very quick to deny responsibility for ourselves and distance ourselves from all negative events. Unfortunately, this has come to extend to our personal lives too.

If there is one thing I pride myself on is trying to be an understanding and non-judgemental human being. I have met people, though, who confuse taking responsibility with admitting fault, and therefore they refuse/avoid/delay taking responsibility at all. We are all shaped by our childhood experiences, past relationships, our genetics, formal and informal education, etc. All these things together shape how we are today. Now, one or more of those things may have been a profound traumatic negative experience that has gone on to shape us significantly – and maybe even negatively. As a result of that experience perhaps we become highly attuned to certain words people say (perhaps words bullies may have used) or to misinterpreting body language or we come to expect that certain words will be followed by physical abuse, etc. When you experienced those things before it was perhaps appropriate to retaliate or go on the defence. The thing is when you are no longer in that situation and you continue to react as if you were, that is when our own actions/defence become our offense. That is when we hurt ourselves more, or others too. Now, as I said, I can understand this and I can forgive this. No one is saying it is your fault you are the way you are; and it’s certainly not your fault those negative things may have happened to you (emotional or physical abuse, etc.), but it is each individual’s responsibility to decide whether they want to continue to be and act the same or to change. I see the person who refuses to change, who points out how it’s not their fault, who perhaps feels guilt but not motivation to change, as someone caught up in victimhood. And as I have stated many times before, we are not victims of our past but rather the creators of our own future. And trust me, there are still plenty of incentives out there for those that do stand up courageously and take responsibility.

Sunday, October 7, 2012

On camaraderie


The rape and death of Jill Meagher in the last fortnight has brought to our attention some things we take for granted in Australia: that it’s not safe in the streets late at night when you’re walking home on your own, especially if you’re a woman. Now, lets assume that we have only just realised this, what now? Yes, we could focus in about how unfair it is that a bad person went and hurt an innocent woman, or focus in about Australia become more unsafe than we previously thought it was. But I wonder if this realisation could in fact serve to inspire positive change, and in fact inspire something that becomes ingrained into our culture and our human social conscience: camaraderie.

When we realised that climbing mountains was dangerous, we went on to recommend spotters. We have spotters when we bench-press weights. We recommend hiking partners. Essentially most activities and sports that have an inherent sense of danger in it make use of the “buddy system”, where one or more people in a group mutually monitor and assist each other. Now, in some cultures the concept of mutually caring and helping the other doesn’t need a name, it is a social expectation. Looking after and caring about and for our friends is a social responsibility most people take on themselves even if they weren’t directly taught it by schools or families. But perhaps the time has come for us to be actively teaching this concept, maybe even as a (social) health promotion strategy.

There are some places in the world that have a higher incidence of crime than others, but even in the “safest” of places, there are still times when crime is more likely to occur than others. A lot of violent crimes happen at night. A lot of crime occurs where they are lots of people gathered. A lot of crime occurs in the context of alcohol or drugs… And so finally back to why Jill Meagher’s tragic story made me think of all this. Of course she did not deserve what happened to her. And of course none of the friends she went out with did anything wrong; they only did what seemed normal to them. And my proposition is that we as a society promote a new kind of normal. Her friends may have offered to take her home and she may politely refused, but rather than place blame on anyone other than the criminal that killed her, I propose we learn from this story and make some changes to prevent other people suffering the same fate as this woman. Lets make camaraderie as common as going out and having a fun time with your friends. Lets promote a social responsibility amongst people, friends we go out for a drink and a laugh with at least. Have it as a rule, even if it’s no longer an instinct in our society, that we care for the people we hang out with when we go out.  That we care from the minute they leave to go hang out with us, and that we care enough also to ensure they get back home safely.

Sunday, August 5, 2012

On excuses, reasons, and choice


I met someone some time ago who had some personality features I didn’t quite like. We were close for a time and so I told her that some of the things she did bothered and sometimes even hurt me. She told me that it was all because that’s just how she was, that that’s how she had turned out after been raped as a teenager by her father. Of course, that is a terrible thing to happen to anyone and I know it takes a lot of courage to tell your own story. And, of course, I also realise that childhood sexual abuse really does mess you up in so many ways! The strangeness of this particular situation was that this friend said to me fairly often “that’s just how I am” and reminded me about her father. I knew; I wasn’t going to forget what she had told me – it was something deeply serious! However, after so many times that she told me that that’s how she is and it’s due to the childhood sexual abuse she had suffered, I remembered that she wasn’t the only person this had happened to. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a very sad and disturbing thing and every single person this happens to will experience it differently and will be affected differently by it in the long-term. However, I felt that with me she was using it as an excuse for her behaviour so as to avoid apology, or – God forbid – change.

I have known a very many people who have been sexually abused as children and not everyone was as mean as this ‘friend’ was to me; they weren’t obligated to be mean by reason of their terrible experiences. When I remembered this, and at the last straw with this friend, I walked away from it all. Yes, I know that people with histories of abuse in childhood are more likely to have a personality disorder in adulthood than those who never had those experiences. And yet I also believe in the human potential for change. I know that you can take away every choice from a child when he is abused. I also know that at some point a child becomes and adult and all adults have the choice to continue to be victims to the past or to progress from there. It’s a choice. My friend wasn’t without awareness of how her personality and the things she said and did hurt others (myself included), and she was a very smart woman academically and creatively. When I told her that something she did or said hurt me, she didn’t say “I’m sorry. I will try not to do it again”. No, she would say, “that’s just how I am. You know with what my dad did to me”. Yes, I knew that. I also knew he wasn’t currently doing that her; she was no longer a victim, she was just choosing to continue to wear the victim cloak as an excuse not to alter her adult behaviour. Finally, it hurt me too much to continue to be her friend when she found it easier to say “this is how I am” than to alter her behaviour to prevent hurting those that were simply trying to be a good friend to her.

Sunday, July 15, 2012

On "the Jews"

I'm on holidays at the moment so here's just a few lines on things I've been thinking about recently.

I just finished reading a book called "Outliers" by Malcolm Gladwell, which I at first thought was about the absolute opposite of what my core beliefs about success are: that everyone has the same innate capacity. And, yes, at first glance it appears to be saying that you can expect to be in low-skill service jobs if you're Latino, you can expect to be good at maths if you're Asian, and you'll probably be a doctor or a lawyer if you're Jewish. And if you're of African descent you'll probably want to kill and physically hurt others for minor slights. Generalizations? Stereotypes? Actually, it deals more on examining the roots of why people turn out to be the way they are based on specific things that happened to the ancestors of their culture, and that for the most part continue to imprint on their futures. An interesting note was made of New York's Jewish community.

In the last week I made my mum visit the Museum of Jewish Heritage in New York with me. Now, she's a very humble woman with a primary school education who can barely pick out the location of countries on a map of the world (e.g. not long ago she was surprised to find out that Spain is in Europe and not in South America like she assumed for a long time). You get my point: she's a humble woman with not a lot of knowledge of what is not essential to her survival. At the Jewish museum while we were looking at concentration camp uniforms and learning about the disgusting things that happened to so many people during WW2, mum asked me, "why did all this happen to the Jews?" I thought it was an excellent question! There's probably no single answer why that did, and there's definitely nothing in this universe to justify it.

What I find even more fascinating, though, is how a great majority of the Jewish community post-WW2 became so prosperous. They were always an oppressed and abused people. They were workers and they had to learn skills. Since thousands of years they've been working (even under slavery conditions) - they had to learn! So the theory goes that around the time of WW2 when dislike of the Jews was quite overt and common, even in the new lands they settled in they were discriminated against for many reasons. So to escape this oppressive environment, Jews after some time used the skills hey had learnt previously, textile and garment industry, for example, and started up their own operations. They hired other Jews. They taught their children the importance of work to better yourself and aiming to equalize opportunity (I maintain that this is the true value of education). The story goes that the children of garment workers went on to become lawyers and doctors and business people at the insistence of their parents - but after they became lawyers (for example) their gentile counterparts still discriminated against them. They ended up working the legal cases nobody wanted, working the medical fields nobody else considered worthy at the time (things like psychiatry and neuroscience, for example). And then, something happened: the Jews had created niches of industry for themselves - which as fate or history would have it, soon became the most sought out niches in industry.

Why did the holocaust happen? I guess there's no valid or all-exhaustive answer to that. But you know what, I believe the best thing the Jewish people ever did was 1) acknowledge their position as others viewed them, and 2) used it not as an excuse to become victims of oppression but to motivate forward action. They were people who once they left the concentration camps, they left the concentration camps. They didn't sit down and feel sorry for themselves for their dreadful pasts and suffering. They began to build instead their prosperous futures. Can't we all learn from that? Once the suffering is done with, let's stop suffering and start building a future we desire.

Sunday, June 10, 2012

On prescription drug abusers


Every now and again all doctors will come across a person who wants to access prescription medications for the wrong reasons. Some people will want them to feed their own personal addictions, and others will resell them for a profit on the streets. Personally, I am never one to judge people for their weakness or for their lifestyle choices, yet this scenario bothers most doctors for a variety of reasons. It bothers me because the false stories these people tell will make me second guess and misjudge the person who tells the same story but it is true and they have a real need for these medications. And, yes, it is also frustrating to have to deal with patients who are lying to you or who abuse your trust or become aggressive/threatening when you challenge them or deny them what they want when all you’re trying to do is get on with your daily job.

There are some government systems in place to help doctors identify people who abuse prescription drugs, but unfortunately they have big limitations. The biggest reason they probably don’t work is that a doctor has to first decide to enquire with them about a specific patient. Now, the patient who is a prescription drug abuser usually knows how not to arouse suspicion from doctors – therefore the doctor never decides to check their background! In medical school they taught us some basic things that should arouse our suspicion that a patient may be a drug abuser, but most drug abusers have figured these out and found ways to deal with us to make us believe they aren’t one of those people we learnt about all those years ago. For example, some of the things we were taught are that drug abusers tend to:
  •          book the last appointment of the day (no, not anymore. If anything, they tend to be morning people)
  •          ask for specific medication (they know how to calculate equivalent doses of whatever you give them if it’s from the same drug class. They also know to ask for an NSAID and paracetamol along with their opiates and benzos)
  •          can’t back up their stories with clinical data (they have scars to prove the “surgery”, the medical report from the hospital, the clinical signs on examination, the old packets of the medication they have been prescribed, the imaging report, the name of the interstate specialist who looks after their condition but is unfortunately unavailable right now, etc.)
  •          they become angry if you question them about drug abuse (“Oh no, doctor, not me. You can even call my specialist – oh wait, he’s not there today”…)
  •          refuse referral or liason with other clinicians (you have to admire these guys’ confidence in their lies. I once was  informed by a hospital oncology department that I was the 15th GP that week that had referred a patient for urgent review– a patient who did not actually have the metastatic cancer the CT report he provided from his interstate doctor, a doctor who knew nothing of the patient either)
Most doctors agree that a solution to the problem of prescribing to patients who abuse prescription medications is to have a real-time system of prescribing where the doctor is alerted to how many times a drug of abuse has already been prescribed to a patient. Would it work? Maybe, or maybe not. I hope it does if it's ever introduced.

To be honest, what bothers me most about the issue of prescription drug abusers is not that I was once duped by an amputee who claimed to be a war veteran but who had in fact lost a limb from intravenous drug use related disease (and not a war injury as he claimed) and I gave a script for opiates to. But that that experience made me doubt the next amputee war veteran I saw who had lost his limb through war injury and had severe phantom limb pain for which his pain specialist had prescribed a whole concoction of drugs, including opiates. Had his specialist not been available and his story backed up, I may well have let him go without receiving the proper medical care he deserved. That is my greatest fear regarding this: not that I feed a junkie’s addiction, but that I commit an injustice to a real and deserving patient.

Sunday, April 1, 2012

On making "the unhappy" happy - Part 2/2

Of the war veterans I meet with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression, do you know what they value most in their lives? Not finding a “cure” for PTSD and depression, but just appreciating and being able to be with the people in their lives. They accept very courageously – not cowardly – the goals of treatment of these disorders: minimizing symptoms, moving forward from the last exacerbation, and decreasing the number of further exacerbations. They don’t seek a cure, though of course if it were feasible, they’d pay any price to have it. But why fight futile battles? So, I say again that they very courageously choose to expend their energies on the things that matter instead: love, productivity, enjoyment. But before you assume that I am making a claim such as “there is no cure for depression”, let me clarify that that is not the broad statement that I am making.

I used to think, naively, that once I fell in love, once someone loved me and I had someone to share my life with, I’d be happy. I wondered why the people I met who had the things that I thought would bring me happiness weren’t happy. How could they be depressed when they had a partner, children, a job they didn’t hate, generally good physical health, etc.? Why hadn’t the love they had in their loves not cured their depression? Because lack of love didn’t bring about the depression, nothing that was correctable did. Yes, they had love; but completely unrelatedly they also had a mental disorder. Finally I realized why people give flowers to sick relatives in hospital: the flower isn’t meant to “cure” the illness, just make it more tolerable by giving you that warm feeling inside that you’re not alone and reminding you that people care about you.

In persons who have become depressed or suffering PTSD as a result of some psychological social trauma, there is nothing in this world that can erase the memories and/or the cognitive processes that get programmed into your brain. Remarkably, though, a human being can go about their lives being perfectly functional and socially involved despite these demons we carry around in our head. When you have a chronic depression or PTSD of this kind, the best you can wish for is not being “cured”, but having people around you who understand you and stick with you on the journey. Not even “love” can erase the inner hell we experience with these mental disorders, but love can motivate the people around us to give us the all vital support and understanding. Conversely, if you find yourself in a relationship with a person who has depression or PTSD or a similar complaint, you will only hurt yourself by believing that your role is to bring about “cure”; it’s not. Your role is no different to that of anyone else who ever loved: to love, to give (including understanding), to receive, and to share life together.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

On making "the unhappy" happy - Part 1/2

One thing that took me a while to understand when I was younger is that “love”, or having a romantic relationship, doesn’t cure everything. In fairy tales, people fall in love and love rids you of physical “ugliness”, of having an evil heart, of disease and death, of financial poverty, of social oppression, of emotional and physical abuse, of low self-esteem, of disability, and of every negative thing that can happen to a human being. And don’t get me wrong, I like those stories as much as anyone else, and I'm also aware they are often metaphors for what love can actually achieve. Essentially love, being in love, being loved, loving, discovering love, etc. has the effect of giving human beings courage to believe in their own strength and to take risks. The greatest motivator for positive change and the strength to bring about that change is love. Love can conquer all…

The second most difficult thing for a human being to do is to bring about change in this world. The single most difficult thing in this life for us to do is to bring about change in ourselves. Love is supposed to make all things possible, right? That’s what the fairy tales tell us. That is what we have learnt personally from life. I still believe this is true. But there is one scenario unique to human beings I find particularly interesting when considering all that love can do.

Depression and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) result in unique states of mind where the “enemy” and the “villain” that we fight everyday lives exclusively within our hearts and minds. He may have been created by exposure to psychologically trauma or neurobiochemical imbalances or social oppression and abuse, or any of a myriad of negative human experiences. Yet the outcome of these situations are so common that someone has been able to make lists of the cognitive effects that result. They are described commonly in books and medical and scientific literature and classified into categories that receive the names of “mood disorders”. Depression, anxiety, and PTSD are very common diagnoses given to the people who suffer the effects of having these internal enemies to fight; the low mood, the lack of self-esteem, the sense of worthlessness, the compulsion to self-harm, the feelings of inability to better one’s own situation, and the inability to envision a future different to the inner world they seem trapped in.

I have seen many patients with PTSD, mainly war veterans, but all survivors of some sort of abuse or extremes of human experience. These people have lived through horrible things – and survived! If anybody can be called strong and honorable, it is them. Yet, they often are the first to believe they don’t deserve to be alive or to have good things in life. Bullets kill many soldiers in combat; depression and PTSD kills way too many survivors. People don’t choose to suffer depression, anxiety, or PTSD, the same way none of us choose to voluntarily suffer. And the worst part is that with these psychiatric complaints, you also can’t choose to “just snap out of it”. The goals of treatment in these disorders are not aimed at cure, but at managing symptoms, learning new ways to process information to help stop triggering these inner beasts, and minimizing the number of exacerbations. Of course, there are many ways we go about doing this (medication, psychotherapy, self-directed education, meditation, etc.), but generally there’s no way to completely cure these problems.

But wait, what about love? Doesn’t love “conquer ALL? Doesn’t love give you strength, courage, motivation, hope, etc. to achieve anything in life – even to change the world? The thing with depression, PTSD, and other psychiatric complaints is that the thing to conquer lies within. But love should be able to help you achieve even that, right? Isn’t love also able to change a human being? I used to believe just that.

Sunday, February 12, 2012

On the dobber's (/victim's) dilemma

I have previously mentioned the difficulty faced by victims of childhood sexual abuse as children and adolescents in telling someone of their predicament. They hesitate due to embarrassment, unwarranted guilt, fear, lack of understanding that they are victims to a terrible sin, and being unaware of the process, etc. Recently I’ve encountered a similar scenario, but in the adult victims of past sexual abuse.

Victims of childhood sexual abuse eventually grow up to become adults. Some become very capable adults, and a lot become crippled by the emotional and psychological scars of trauma. A lot of the people we encounter on a day to day basis have been past victims of this worst of crimes, most have never told a soul of their experiences. I want now to discuss a composite of this person, let’s call her Elisabeth.

An Unpleasant Story 
Elizabeth was sexually abused by Josef between the ages of 10 and 14. Josef was Elisabeth’s stepfather, who joined the family just before Elisabeth’s 10th birthday. Elisabeth told Rosemarie, her mother, of Josef’s behaviour towards her, the fondling, etc. She did this when she was 14 and then the abuse stopped. Rosemarie had some “stern” words with Josef, but eventually she was a woman in love and they decided to put this “episode” behind them and move forward with family life. The “episode” was never discussed with police or counsellors or anyone else who may have cared. Rosemarie and Josef remain together to this day. Elisabeth, somehow, finally managed to escape the rape dungeon she called a home.

Elisabeth became a woman of her own, independent, self-sufficient, struggled with some things but succeeded in others; she was just a normal woman with a past most of us would never wish on our worst enemies. But the past was in the past and the past can’t hurt you, right? I don’t know that that is right. Elisabeth had managed to move ahead with her life, leaving the past behind, until one day the past came back to find her. Sounds clichéd, right? Yes, but it also sounds horrible and unfair.

One day Elisabeth found out that Josef was accused of doing some things she knew he was capable of, things she had witnessed at one time when she had been the victim of such things. But this was a separate incident, separate incidentS, things not related to her at all, but it brought to her consciousness something that she had suspected all along: that she was not Josef’s only ever victim. There had been others, there probably would be more… And whenever we read this scenario the answer seems so simple: tell. Elisabeth should tell her story, right? Elisabeth should do the right thing for the greater good, right?

Imagine yourself in Elisabeth’s shoes. In the movies and episodes of Law & Order: SVU what happens is that the Elisabeth-character tells her story, feels good about herself, saves the day, the baddie goes to prison forever, and everyone has a perfect life thereafter. Reality is not like the movies. Elisabeth knows this.
Elisabeth asks some people for advice; should she “assist” the potential case against Josef? This isn’t about her life or the things that happened to her, this is about doing the allegedly right thing. Everyone tells her, ‘yes, of course, you HAVE to tell your story’, it’s her duty. The thing is Elisabeth has a life now. She has left that past behind and she owes no-one anything for getting where she is. Who does she owe? Josef’s other victims? The “general public”? Why? She suffered too, but how does that make her anything other than a victim? And will she really feel better to tell her story, to become the hero that saves the fate of children she’s never met and owes nothing to? Doing good things makes everyone feel good, we’re told… And yet I feel that no one should feel coerced to re-live any pain except for their own self.

How do we convince Elisabeth to do the “right” thing? What is the right thing to do? This is the dilemma of knowing something that incriminates someone, but that also inadvertedly incriminates you too. I know you’re thinking ‘but how does that incriminate her if she tells her story?’ Josef maybe or maybe doesn’t get prison time. Elisabeth is punished by having to re-live pain of her story, the humiliation and embarrassment of discussing the very personal and degrading things done to her, she is faced by the well-meaning but hurtful murmurs that if she had told earlier none of those other victims should have had to suffer what they did. Is it worth it? Is the sacrifice worth it for Elisabeth? Forget for a second the “general public”, the “greater good”, is all this worth it to Elisabeth? What will she gain by telling her story?... It’s easy to answer that, but not if you’re truly only thinking of Elisabeth. The only person thinking of Elisabeth – and for a long time – has only being Elisabeth.

And if Elisabeth doesn’t tell her story and Josef goes on to abuse other children, is it Elisabeth’s fault or is it Josef’s? Elisabeth was a victim. Before we judge her, we have to understand her dilemma. Sometimes it’s enough to be a survivor without being a hero.

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

On the Eminem thing

People think I’m trying to be purposely funny when I describe myself in the “About Me” section as being like Eminem. I’ll be the first to admit I’ve never met Marshall Mathers III, and I’ve never even had the good fortune of being to an Eminem concert. I identify a lot with most of the lyrics of Eminem’s songs, though. A lot of people must; he sells records in the millions of copies. Personally I believe he is a great expressionist, and not only that, he has a very common human story.

There is an Eminem song (Same song & dance) where he is considering different ways to tell his crush how he feels about her (he’s a shy, socially-awkward person like so many of us) and he postulates: "Should I cut off one of my ears and mail it to her? Send her pictures of my collections of skeletons? Or footage of me impaling myself on an elephant's tusk?" This kind of strategy may not occur to everyone, but it does to Eminem because he is he and he thinks the way he does… I keep a small collection of animal skeletons and to me Eminem’s proposition of sharing something dear to him does not seem strange.

I won’t go try to analyse Eminem’s lyrics for anyone, but I would like to share some of them which are the reason I identify with him so much. I guess, the way Jorge Luis Borge’s words always come to mind: ‘each man is every man’ and each man’s story is shared by every man. I have been the “dark phase” Eminem, as much as I have been the Eminem who rejoices in his blessings. We all have to different degrees, I think J

I'm not afraid /To take a stand
Everybody /Come take my hand
We'll walk this road together, through the storm
Whatever weather, cold or warm
Just lettin’ you know that you're not alone
Holla if you feel like you've been down the same road…

****
I got some skeletons in my closet /and I don't know if no one knows it /So before they thrown me inside my coffin and close it /I'm-a expose it... (Cleaning Out my Closet)

Well since age twelve, I've felt like I'm someone else /’Cause I hung my original self from the top bunk with a belt...
And by the way, when you see my dad, /Tell him that I slit his throat in this dream I had. (My Name is)

All I know is I don't want to follow in the footsteps of my dad /’cause I hate him so bad /The worst fear that I had /was growing up to be like his f*ckin’ ass /Man if you could understand /why I am the way that I am... I never dreamt I'd get to the level that I'm at /This is whack! This is more than I ever could have asked... (Saying Goodbye to Hollywood)

Yo, never was a thug, just infatuated with guns...
/I'm a soldier, these shoulders hold up so much /They won't budge, I'll never fall or fold up... (Soldier)

My thoughts are sporadic /I act like I'm an addict /I rap like I'm addicted to smack... (‘Til I Collapse)

Sometimes I feel so alone /I just don't know /feels like I been down this road before /So lonely and cold /it's like something takes over me /Soon as I go home and close the door. (Deja Vu)

I'm just so f*ckin' depressed /I just can seem to get out this slump... I think I'm starting to lose my sense of humour /Everything is so tense and gloom... (Beautiful)

Sometimes I even cut myself to see how much it bleeds /It's like adrenaline, the pain is such a sudden rush for me...
But what's this sh*t you said about you like to cut your wrists too? /I say that sh*t just clownin’, dog /C'mon, how f*cked up is you? /You got some issues, Stan. I think you need some counselling... (Stan)

If I, were to die murdered in cold blood tomorrow /Would you feel sorrow or show love, or would it matter?...
But there's way too much at stake for me to be fake /There's too much on my plate, I’ve come way /too far in this game to turn and walk away...
The only way I'm leavin’ this bitch is suicide... I'm not what ya think /I appear to be f*cked up, mentally endangered /I can't stay away from a razor...
 It hurts when you see your friends turn their back on you, dog /And you ain't got nothing’ left but your word and your balls /And you're stressed from the calls of your new friends /Begging with their hands out...
Death itself can hurt me /Just the thought of dyin’ alone that really irks me (When the Music Stops)

Sometimes I think, there's nothing to live for /I almost break down and cry /Sometimes I think I'm crazy; I'm crazy, oh so crazy! /Why am I here? Am I just wastin’ my time?..
People make jokes, cos they don't understand me /They just don't see my real side /I act like shit don't phase me /Inside it drives me crazy /My insecurities could eat me alive... Sometimes it feels like the world's on my shoulders /Everyone's leanin’ on me /Sometimes it feels like the world's almost over... (Hailie’s Song)

I never would have dreamed in a million years I'd see /so many motherf*ckin’ people, who feel like me /Who share the same views and the same exact beliefs /It's like a f*ckin ARMY marching in back of me (White America)

Yet everybody just feels like they can relate /I guess words are a motherf*cker, they can be great /or they can degrade. Or even worse, they can teach hate /It's like these kids hang on every single statement we make /like they worship us... They say music can alter moods and talk to you /Well can it load a gun up for you and cock it too?... That's why we sing for these kids who don't have a thing /except for a dream and a f*ckin’ rap magazine /Who post pin-up pictures on they walls all day long /Idolize they favourite rappers and know all they songs /Or for anyone who's ever been through sh*t in they lives /'Til they sit and they cry at night wishin’ they'd die /'Til they throw on a rap record and they sit and they vibe /We're nothin to you - but we're the f*ckin’ sh*t in they eyes /That's why we seize the moment, try to freeze it and own it /Squeeze it and hold it, cause we consider these minutes golden /And maybe they'll admit it when we're gone, just let our spirits live on /through our lyrics that you hear in our songs... (Sing For the Moment)

(If it looks like you’ve seen this before, I have posted most of it on my facebook notes before.)

Monday, January 2, 2012

On me... and turning 30

It’s funny, if you ask some people who have really gotten to know me intimately they’ll tell you that I have several different personalities. These people have at times asked me who is the “real” Vanessa. I can tell you straight out that ALL of them are. If you’d met me some years ago and asked me to list the things that to me are the most important in life I would have told you: family, love, expression, enjoyment, spirituality, and work. If you met me at another point in my life I would have answered exactly the same thing – but in a different order! That is where my “inconsistencies” lie, but actually I am just very average J

The self-hating years
The single most hurtful thing ever said to me was “you’ve had a perfect life”. Yeah, it was hurtful because it was said by someone close to me who obviously didn’t know me much at all. I don’t believe there are such things as perfect lives or perfect childhoods, everyone does the best with what they’re given. I don’t know if I am (or was?) autistic to a degree, but I never really connected with anyone as a child. And it didn’t bother me to have no friends; I was quite happy in my own inner world, my make-believe play, and reading books to learn something that interested me. At age 10 I was faced with circumstances that are actually very common in most cultures but that I would never wish upon anyone. As a result of this I lost the ability to trust, to believe, to feel safe and worthwhile. From then on I started hating more than just my own physical self, but also my future self, believing that I deserved nothing good to ever come to me in my life. It was very draining, and my inner world grew increasingly darker and I became more and more self-deprecating.

At about the age of 20, after I had finished my undergraduate degree in science, the self-loathing and self-denial of my own need to be human finally climaxed. I started psychotherapy for the first time then. What came of it? My single greatest victory was to forgive those that had hurt me and to forgive myself for being hurt. It seems so miniscule and meaningless that I can summarise it in one sentence, but the amount of healing the simple act of swapping the words “sorry” for “thank you” is hardly able to be explained. I finally stopped apologising for being Vanessa, for allowing myself as a child to be hurt, and I stopped apologising for the simple fact of being alive. Instead I started to be grateful to be alive and I allowed myself to have (and not feel guilty about having) human needs of personal fulfilment and achievement. It was a very slow process to accept myself, to disrobe myself of the self-loathing, to finally become and be comfortable in being Vanessa in all my forms.

At 24 my curiosity and interest in spiritual matters brought me to commit to Christianity after having studied several theological and philosophical systems for many years. What lead me to finally make this commitment was that I came to understand that it’s ok to not be perfect, it’s human nature, and that the ability to feel connection to God is not barred to me or anyone else regardless of their past, present, or future. That was spiritual commitment and to some extent also fulfilment. During and after this time I also gradually learnt to not hate or feel ashamed of my physical appearance, of my lack of social skills, of my naivety, and of all these things I had for which I felt I couldn’t be like “normal” people. I guess in all this I may have eventually overshot the mark  :P

The self-loving years
I was around 26 before I could bear the thought of being ok with being seeing as me, as a complete and separate person of my own. I guess by that stage I had allowed people to get to know me, all aspects of me, and to become my friends who I could trust and expect some trust and caring in return. I grew more confident in many things also. I finally was not afraid or concerned to be seen for me. I was nearly 27 before I finally allowed myself to remove my clothes off in front of another human being – someone of my choosing and with my full consent. This part was the hardest step for me, the rest was quite easy. And in fact it probably got to be a bit too easy J

My mistake was that after I learnt to love myself, I probably started to love only myself. I started to consider romantic partners as purely things to increase my own enjoyment and happiness. They say that people with histories of abuse most often become either one of two things in their future relationships: the abuser or the abused. I had decided from when I was 20 and started therapy, that I would never again be a victim of abuse. And so here I was, playing out another role. I had never had a time in my life when I didn’t feel guilty about being alive, but maybe at times it would have been good to at least feel pity for others. Needless to say, several  partners later, I still wasn’t a winner. Despite me finally being able to love myself and form sort of bonds with others, I still hadn’t learnt what it was like to love others. I mean, of course, what it was like to be in love.

The loving years
Wait, having sex and making love aren’t the same things?... No. I eventually learnt that too. June 2010, or sometime after that, I fell in love for the first time in my life! How did I know it was different? Because I found myself missing someone else, wanting someone else’s approval, feeling safe and confident to be associated with someone, feeling a part of something very special. It didn’t last long and I was a different kind of sad to what I’d previously known when it ended. But you know what bothered me most about it ending? Because after all those years it had taken me to convince myself that I was a worthy human being, the overwhelming message I was getting was that I wasn’t worthy of another being’s sacrifice to be with me. My partner wouldn’t sacrifice any of the things I would have sacrificed in a heartbeat to be with them. And that hurt me so much. It was like being told all over again that I wasn’t a worthy human being. But this time I didn’t believe it for long, because sometimes all you can do is let go and remember that regardless of what someone may think of me, I am still Vanessa.

And then the unthinkable happened and I fell in love for the second time in my life. Wow! What a blessing it was. It was beyond what I had ever imagined;  my new love met and exceeded every standard I ever had. This was truly the love of my life, the one person you could have sworn was fabricated purely using every guideline for a good person I had in my mind. Words can’t do this story justice. Of course, I was in love with this person so you’d be right in saying I am biased, but I didn’t care what anyone had to say. The only approval I needed in this world was from this one person . Truly, never have I felt so secure, so safe, so myself, so part of something greater than special, than when I was part of this partnership. Then the worst thing happened! The worst thing to have happened to me at this moment in time after what I’ve been through, I mean. There were reasons for it, but I was left alone again. I only wish I had been given a chance to correct my flaws, that whatever good was at first seen in me (what I think I see in myself too) would have been worthy of another chance, of a sacrifice. Or am I really not as worthy as I think I am?

The years of being loved
I hope in future to be loved, but it’s not enough just to be loved here and now. I hope to have someone fall in love with me truly, to want me, to wish to be with me, and that this wish is enough to motivate the things every successful relationship needs: compromise and self-sacrifice. I am worth it, right? I think I am. It’s been 30 years, and I’m ready to be loved the way I eventually learnt to love too. I am ready for so many things. But I am ready mostly to say that only God can judge me for my life.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

On fate

If you know me, you'll know how I credit Napoleon Hill for the great change in my life that came about in 2006. Napoleon Hill wrote "motivational" material of the kind we commonly associate with self-help books. Throughout the years since, I've read a lot of material from Napoleon Hill and other similar writers, including Tony Robbins.

Back in 2006 I was in a bit of a dark hole, emotionally and spiritually. I took a year off medical school to sort myself out. To re-evaluate not only if I wanted to finish my course, but also if my total existence was worthy of effort. I didn't feel hard-done by the world; I just had allowed myself to exist without a known cause to justify my existence. Now, not many people will go through these "existential crises" because we are either in good environments with supportive people, or we have external passions, or quite simply questioning your reason for existence is just not something that would capture our attention at all given all the other tasks of life. I, however, like to question everything. So I started questioning and I just couldn't identify many reasons why I should continue to be alive. I at that stage wasn't suicidal, no, that's not what I mean. I did however "wish" for an alternative to my current life. I wished for disease, for sudden death, for a road accident, for natural disasters, etc. But it wasn't all negative, I also wished for "love", for money even, for artistic success, for a child, for anything that would take me out of my then empty life to elsewhere. I wanted anything, good or bad - as long as it came to me and I didn't have to do anything to get it. I believed that fate had brought me to this slump, but that it would equally bail me out. It was then I started reading Napoleon Hill's work and realized that all these things, these "good" things that happened to some “lucky” people (unlike myself) didn't just happen due to fate.

Napoleon Hill tells a story at the start of the book 'Success Through a Positive Mental Attitude' about a poor family in which the child asks his mother why his family is poor. The child is pondering his own “fate” to grow up and become a poor man himself like every other member of his family. Now, the obvious response seems at first to be 'we're poor because our parents were poor like their parents before them, etc.' Or ‘we’re poor because we can’t afford the type of education others can’. Or ‘we’re poor because we are of this race, or culture, or religion, etc’. However, is it an unchangeable fate that some families or some people are born either poor or successful? The mother explains "We are poor, not because of God. We are poor because... no-one in our family has ever developed a desire to be anything else”. Now that seems like a simple statement, but if you consider that the family in question was an African-American family, not too many generations removed from slavery and oppression, and that the child that asked the question became a very wealthy businessman, you can begin to understand the paralysing effect our belief in fate can bring.

In relationships many of us believe that fate will bring us the “right” man or woman. And not only that, we also believe that fate will determine the length or strength of that relationship. Fate will decide if we have children or not. Fate will decide if we have a “good” or a “bad” partner and whether we ourselves are good or bad. So no longer are we in control of the relationship, or of our role in it, but this external entity we call fate is. Why try, then, if it is all up to fate? The other comfortable position we can adopt is to say we are simply bad at relationships. And we may well have reasons to be bad at relationships; maybe we didn’t have the best role models, maybe we have low self-esteem due to any number of things, maybe we had a prejudicial childhood or subject to trauma somewhere in our past. All these things shape us, of course, but insight is often the first key to unlock us from this uncontrollable thing called fate. However, you can unlock a person from slavery, from trauma, and then it is up to the person to walk out of his/her cell. As a result of all the abuse and trauma maybe the person is initially too weak to walk through the door alone, but how long should we keep using that excuse? After a week? A month? A year? Ten years? The rest of our lives? It’s really up to the individual person, isn’t it? We may not have been responsible for our pasts but we are in control to shape our futures. Things don’t always just happen to us, some things we can make happen too. Acknowledging that is isn’t accepting blame for our pasts; it is accepting the challenge to steer our own future.

Similarly in our careers or vocational aspirations. Too often I hear people tell me that they wish they could do that job but they’re doing this other one because not many people get to do that job. But somebody will get those jobs, right? Why can’t that somebody be you? People will then proceed to tell you excuses (aka “reasons”) why they believe it can’t be them. They need more education, those jobs are for people who know other people, you need money to get into that field, you would need to relocate elsewhere, etc. So? The great thing about these “reasons” are that perhaps you in fact need to see them as steps rather than excuses. So if you have to know someone, why not get yourself known to someone? If you need more education, why not apply for a further education course? See, yet it is so easy to say that fate would have it that you don’t (yet) know the right people, you don’t (yet) have the money, etc. We become victims of our fate and also of our past – and that is how we remain stagnant. We may in time come to blame fate for the job we don’t have, the money we don’t earn, the associates we can’t exactly call friends. It is easy to blame an external entity – but we don’t have to be victims of any past or future if we take responsibility for our role in our own lives.

The last thing I want to consider is our great fear of control, or what is more commonly called accountability. I know, I know, we think we all want control, right? Everyone wants control, but no-one wants to be held accountable for their actions. So we hesitate to dream, to aspire to anything, to want or demand change. We would rather place our faith in this mystical thing called fate. ‘If fate will have it, I will have a good marriage. If fate will have it, I will enjoy this new job. If fate will have it, I will be financially successful in my career...’ People look to horoscopes to fuel their faith. If a thing I want is suggested by my horoscope, then it is okay to want it. If my horoscope says I am not to have something, then I am bound to have this fate happen to me. Now, you may have heard of this thing called self-fulfilling prophecies. I speak of it in terms of horoscopes because it is the most obvious example. Often a horoscope will tell you a general bit of information that describes you – ok, you agree with it (e.g. “oh yes, I am calm like other virgos). Then it tells you something vague but positive about what will happen to you – and you can always identify at least one instance of this happening. For example, ‘you will meet a handsome stranger’ can mean that guy that looked at you on the bus. You were alert to this and so you see your destiny being fulfilled. Had you not been alerted to the fact you may not even have noticed anyone on the bus even if he was very overtly trying to capture your attention. Similarly, it may be with career success, financial wealth, etc. It is like we are free to allow good things to happen to us – or god forbid and we actually act in order to have good things happen to us – only if we are devoid of the accountability for our futures. Accountability becomes a thing to shun not only in regard to negative consequences, but also in potentially positive ones. No one wants to say they tried and did not succeed at this instance. It is so much easier to say that it was our fate to fail.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

On doing it all over again

There’s a saying in Spanish that says that man is the only species to trip on the same stone twice. In fact, I remember reading in a neuroscience text once about how homo sapiens is the only species that despite having suffered an adverse reaction to something that they ate, would be willing to eat it again. Are we stupid? Or are we the only species capable of hope?

Behavioural research experiments have shown that almost any living animal can be “taught” to respond in a predictable manner. You show a dog food and they instinctively salivate. You show a dog some food and sound a bell at the same time and the dog salivates. You do that enough times and the dog will come to associate the bell (not just food – and in fact, soon only the bell without the food) with salivation. You can train almost any animal to respond like this.

Most animals can also “teach” themselves (or their trainers) to respond in a certain manner. For example, a pigeon may notice once that when he spun to the right, he received a food reward. He will spin to the right again and see if he gets more food. Maybe he does, maybe he doesn’t, but it’s worth another shot, right? Of course, look at what’s at stake! There’s a perceived benefit to doing something in a particular way. Soon, the pigeon may find himself spinning and spinning, awaiting his reward and perhaps only erratically receiving it. Maybe he has to spin ten times before he is rewarded just once, the next time maybe only twice, the next feed may be 100 spins away – but it always seems so worth it!

The scenario described above about the pigeon is often quoted as an example of how almost any living creature is capable of superstition. A person or animal can do something because they believe they will receive a particular response, regardless of whether the behavior and the reward are causally linked. This belief can consist of a primitive or instinctive behavior in any animal or it can be a complex behavior derived from a complex centralized neurophysiological process (such as a ‘planned’ behavior initiated in a human cerebral cortex). Now, along with the concept of superstition comes the concept of addiction. A creature can derive so much pleasure from a thing (food, physical sensation, drug, drink, etc.), that he will continue to engage in repetitive behavior in order to attain it. He can continue to engage in the behavior even when he only seldom receives the reward, or even when as a result of behaving a certain way he suffers negatively. Why does this happen? Because some things seem so worth it!

We are very much like animals in some ways, and yet why is the human species different to other complex animals? Is it the cerebral cortex and its ability to house our sense of conscious planning, to perceive time, to exercise self-control, and to delay pleasure for perceived greater reward? Or is it our ability to hope and believe - even when what we believe is not biologically advantageous? To believe in things like love.

Most higher species are capable of caring for their young and will engage in what to the human eye appears to be affection. But can other animals love? What is love? I pose this question because love is one of the most addictive things on this planet. The reward, the pleasure in it, is that warm sensation of being "in love" and - if we're lucky enough - also of being loved. You fall in love and you forget about all those other times you thought you were in love. You forget of how much it hurt, you forget how hard it is to make any relationship work, you forget that every interaction with another human being will involve friction regardless of how much the people involved love each other. You risk hurting again. You risk losing. You risk your time, efforts, and emotional investment. You risk it even though you know the statistics. We tell ourselves 'no, this time it'll be perfect, we'll make it work, etc.' The reality is that from one relationship to the next we change very little yet expect a different result, a much more pleasant and successful result, each time. That is the stuff of superstitions, of addiction, of madness. And yet we do it. We fall in love again and again like a junkie addicted to the high. And we do it all because taking the risk - and the potential reward – seems AND IS so damn worth it!

Sunday, January 30, 2011

On something unpleasant

Today I want to discuss something really unpleasant. I want to discuss it because I believe everyone, especially those who have children, have to at least intellectually contemplate this so they may never have to deal with this personally.

One of the most ignorant things I ever heard when I was a kid was a family friend of ours saying that a child from our neighbourhood had lied about being sexually abused. I guess what I found so ignorant about it was the spite (towards the child not the abuser) that she said it with. The story was that a child from our neighbourhood had confessed to her family that years before a male family friend/relative had sexually abused her. The abuser was well-known in the community as a “nice, normal guy”. He had many adult friends, one of which was this woman that said the child was lying, and there was nothing on the surface abnormal about him. The reason this woman said the child must have been lying was because she did not believe that the person named as the abuser looked like a “bad guy”, or that a child could hold a secret for that long, or that no child was “stupid” enough to allow sexual abuse to occur. Those ignorant things are what really stirred in me the need to better educate people on childhood sexual abuse. I can’t imagine anything more damaging than allowing people to believe that children are sexually abused because of the child’s own fault.

I wasn’t able to completely put my thoughts together on what exactly about childhood sexual abuse was not properly understood, and I guess I never should have expected to because the information was hard to come by and the topic is generally avoided. Then as a medical student some years ago when I was doing my mental health rotation, one of our supervisors suggested I read an article about the childhood sexual abuse accommodation syndrome. We were on a ward where the majority of patients were women with personality disorders, and almost invariably, a childhood history of sexual abuse so he thought it beneficial to understand a little of their background. The article was written in 1983 by Ronald Summit and I’ll briefly summarise what it talks about.

The childhood sexual abuse accommodation syndrome describes in a sort of timeline how the sexual abuse of children comes about and then the social and family-dynamic consequences of it. The process is generally broken down in five steps: 1) Secrecy, 2) Helplessness, 3) Entrapment and accommodation, 4) Delayed, conflicted and unconvincing disclosure, 5) Retraction.

1) Secrecy.
Who most commonly abuses children? Parents, stepparents, uncles, siblings, close family friends, teachers, religious ministers, etc. – essentially people in positions of trust to a family. Why they do it is a completely different discussion which I won’t go into here. The general belief is that it’s not a sexual-gratification motive, but rather one of establishing control. I believe it is probably both because generally these “nice people” who wouldn’t hurt a fly (hence their trusted roles in communities) have sexual feelings that for whatever reason are deflected onto children. Maybe they lack self-esteem in approaching other adults for sexual intimacy, maybe they see themselves as children themselves because of their own stunted emotional development, maybe they find the prepubescent physical characteristics of children more arousing than the adult physique, etc. Whatever the reason may be, the factor that unfortunately completes this equation to allow sexual abuse to happen is that children more than just been vulnerable, are also usually actively seeking of affection and from adults – and it is this that paedophiles take advantage of. The child is sworn to secrecy while the abuse goes on, and in return (at least initially) he receives very special and personal attention from their abuser. The secrecy of it all is perpetuated by the fact that the abuser either directly threatens harm to the child or family, or it is understood that if he/she discloses the abuse that he/she will generally face negative consequences of the likes of separating a family unit, admitting “wrong-doing”, facing shame in revealing the details of the abuse, etc.

2) Helplessness.
As a consequence of the sworn secrecy, the child is then locked into a helpless situation where he/she can’t tell anyone of the abuse and is also too physically and/or psychologically immature to fight off the abuser. A child may not like being hurt or sexually humiliated, but he also has a sense of not wanting to hurt the parent/friend/sibling, etc. that is abusing them. Children are way more self-sacrificial than we realize. On the other hand, it’s also possible the child is either precociously or physiologically passing through puberty where the sexual stimulation that the abuser procures for his advantage is also exciting to the child. This is an absolutely normal physical response, but one that the abuser will use to try to justify the abuse and may also extend the period of time the abuse occurs for. The child will eventually experience guilt but finds himself in a position where confessing the abuse also feels like admitting wrongdoing, and experiencing shame as a result of this. In this helpless situation the abuse is able to persist.

3) Entrapment and accommodation.
A person caught in a situation that they can’t physically escape from or stop, naturally develops psychological defences that allow them to distance themselves from the abuse. Children, even very young children, can learn to disassociate from unpleasant realities by psychologically separating their external/physical experience from their internal world. These defence mechanism are what allows the child to survive, but they often will then extend into other aspects of the child’s life, and will often stick with them through to adulthood. A child can eventually become an adult that is difficult to engage emotionally, that flees from emotionally-confronting situations like romantic relationships. Also, the abuse itself can become the punishment the child feels they deserve because they internalize their involvement in a “bad” situation as being a result of themselves being bad. People can go on for years perpetually recreating their childhoods in order to punish themselves, to attempt to “fix” a previous pattern (and inevitably instead repeating it), and also recreating the situations they know they can survive even though these situations were never pleasant. As an example of this, consider the fact that most people that were abused in childhood were often abused by more than one aggressor. Were they asking for it? No, of course not! But behaviourally they had come to know techniques (perhaps sexually-arousing techniques) that they had from personal experience known to please certain adults with paedophilic tendencies. We’ve all known of a precocious child and yet understood that they are a child and their behaviour was not something to take advantage of. Imagine a similar child who is only recreating what a previous abuser had “taught” them, and incidentally in their community encounters another abuser. A child may enter one after another child-abuser relationship. The child’s behaviour becomes both shaped by and perpetuates a life of abuse.

4) Delayed, conflicted and unconvincing disclosure.
Eventually a child, or more commonly an adult, will confess past sexual abuse. This is usually the first step in the healing process, which is why it is such a shame that most people don’t get past this step. The reason most people do eventually confess is not to seek punishment for the abuser but rather as a cathartic experience to free themselves from internal conflict. This is one thing that the adult parent or caretaker often misunderstands and for that reason many children are thought to be “making up stories” about a stepparent/sibling/teacher, etc. People also question the person’s confession because they don’t believe the abuser, such a trusted community member, would be capable of taking advantage of a child for sexual gratification; or they don’t understand why a child would delay this confession. This last reason is so hurtful because it is such a self-centered reason. The adult caretaker to whom the confession is made has certain concepts of themselves, as we all do. They believe themselves to be approachable, trustworthy, caring, protective of the child, and also with good judgement in the people they associate with and allow near their child. For this person to believe the child’s story is also to question their own integrity in their child-rearing abilities, to allow themselves to share in the blame. Of course, this is not the case! The true fact is that the abuser abuses the child AND the caretakers’ trust. A caretaker may seek to know exact details of acts committed and will interrogate the already ashamed and frightened child for this embarrassing information. The child, in turn, as a result of previous disassociation techniques that allowed them to survive the abuse, may not even be able to recall exact details, and so the child’s testimony is considered unreliable by questioning adults. In all, at a time of such crisis, blame is what is thrown around rather than proceeding from them on to soothe the child who is facing all sorts of new conflicts now too.

5) Retraction.
The family and/or the community is thrown into turmoil. People side with either the child or the abuser and seek to punish one or the other. Others disagree in the disclosure altogether because it may tarnish a respected member of society’s reputation. The child, as he has learnt before that he is ‘bad’ and brings about ‘bad’ things, believes the whole turmoil is his sole fault for disclosing what he could have continued to keep quite. As I mentioned before, children can be way more self-sacrificial than we realise, and as such a large proportion of the children who once admitted childhood sexual abuse, will then go on to retract their confession in order to return order, trust, and harmony to a family or community. It’s sad because the story people come to conclude is that there was a child who accused someone of sexually abusing them, but then he confessed he was lying about it all. That to me, is the sad thing about how misunderstood this issue is.

Thanks for reading. And, please, keep this in mind if you’re ever in a position to help a child or someone who has gone through this hell.

Saturday, December 11, 2010

On ‘childish’ people and abuse

I met a lady in Chile who asked me if I knew why some people are just so childish. She was talking about members of her own family, and I guess she asked me because she thought I might have learnt something about this in my psychology classes. I didn’t. I had read a little about post-abuse syndromes, though (e.g. the child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome). Now, an example of the “childish” behaviour she was talking about is two adult siblings bickering and maybe even physically confronting each other, divulging each other’s secrets in order to offend or hurt the other, pitting other family members against each other, etc. Immature behaviour? Yes. Childish? Maybe not the best word to use; children often lack the noxious intent adults seem to use. There are many adults, though, who having the skills and abilities of an adult, behave (and usually also think) as children.

I don’t mean adults acting like children in a derogatory way. I mean adults acting in “immature” ways, as in the mature versus immature coping mechanisms psychology tells us about. For example, say someone cuts you off in traffic. The mature thing to do is acknowledge you’ve been wronged, but given that the situation is fleeting and didn’t result in greater harm, you acknowledge your emotion (anger, sadness, etc.) and move on. The immature thing to do is to scream your head off at the other driver, maybe tailgate him, maybe become physically abusive if you get the chance to. The reason it would be an immature thing to do is because the reaction is disproportionate to the slight – and because you didn’t exercise self-control in response to the emotion you felt. OK, so there are immature and mature behaviours or responses that are designated as such by social norms, moral and psychosocial values, prevalence rates, etc. Now, the very same things that determine whether a behaviour is a mature or an immature response usually have to be learnt – and often in childhood. You can see this way that if you didn’t learn these things in childhood, how to behave “maturely”, the only way you know to respond is in a child-like manner: instinct and survival based, with immediacy, and without regulation of affect.

One of the things I remember reading about children who are abused (whether emotionally, physically, sexually, or whatever other horrible way we have to inflict suffering) is that their emotional development is gravely stunted. These children will have normal psychosocial and cognitive development until the point where they encounter the abuse, then will often remain in that stage of psychocognitive development until adulthood. You can see, therefore, how it follows that individuals that behave childishly are doing so because that is all they know. They react and act like a child because they haven’t learnt any other way to be. Of course, on the receiving end of it, when you as an adult encounter these people who are also physically adult like yourself, you expect them to act like you would and when they don’t we label them as childish.

So that is what I told my friend in Chile, that that at least was my understanding of how some people act the way they do. But in telling this story, you also must think about the people that have the background of childhood abuse and who have learnt to behave more maturely than a child would.

Abuse tends to rid us of many choices, of many liberties and human rights, and especially in childhood can be absolutely shattering to a person. But for those that are fortunate enough, to have escaped childhood abuse and reached a plateau into adult life, there is one choice, one moment of insight, that is all-empowering: making the choice of continuing to be the abused child of the past or becoming the adult that takes responsibility for his/her future experiences. Of course, I am trivializing a lot of things, and sorting through the behaviours and thought patterns of previous abuse victims, identifying the cognitive errors that have been laid down over repeated exposure to abuse, and eventually changing these behaviours, can take years (if ever achieved). The hardest thing to do isn’t doing all the cognitive work, however, it is that first step: believing that you, even you as a victim of abuse, now have power to decide to change things. To me, the difference between two people who have suffered childhood abuse, one who is mature and one who is immature in his interrelational style is that one of them had a moment of insight when he finally understood the words:

“You’re not powerless. You are not sick. You did not deserve what you got, but things can be better.”

Now, my friend in Chile is a very mature, very humble, and very loving person. When I told her about how some of these ‘childish’ people possibly had a troubled childhood, and are possibly cognitively and emotionally stuck there through little fault of their own, she bowed her head down as if remembering some distant memory only she knows about and told me how she really did feel sorry for her family members, even if they did act so negatively and immaturely towards others. And I guess that’s the other point I wanted to make, that perhaps instead of been irritated by these “childish” people, we take a moment to reflect on how sad their lives have probably been.