Showing posts with label ptsd. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ptsd. Show all posts

Sunday, August 5, 2012

On excuses, reasons, and choice


I met someone some time ago who had some personality features I didn’t quite like. We were close for a time and so I told her that some of the things she did bothered and sometimes even hurt me. She told me that it was all because that’s just how she was, that that’s how she had turned out after been raped as a teenager by her father. Of course, that is a terrible thing to happen to anyone and I know it takes a lot of courage to tell your own story. And, of course, I also realise that childhood sexual abuse really does mess you up in so many ways! The strangeness of this particular situation was that this friend said to me fairly often “that’s just how I am” and reminded me about her father. I knew; I wasn’t going to forget what she had told me – it was something deeply serious! However, after so many times that she told me that that’s how she is and it’s due to the childhood sexual abuse she had suffered, I remembered that she wasn’t the only person this had happened to. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a very sad and disturbing thing and every single person this happens to will experience it differently and will be affected differently by it in the long-term. However, I felt that with me she was using it as an excuse for her behaviour so as to avoid apology, or – God forbid – change.

I have known a very many people who have been sexually abused as children and not everyone was as mean as this ‘friend’ was to me; they weren’t obligated to be mean by reason of their terrible experiences. When I remembered this, and at the last straw with this friend, I walked away from it all. Yes, I know that people with histories of abuse in childhood are more likely to have a personality disorder in adulthood than those who never had those experiences. And yet I also believe in the human potential for change. I know that you can take away every choice from a child when he is abused. I also know that at some point a child becomes and adult and all adults have the choice to continue to be victims to the past or to progress from there. It’s a choice. My friend wasn’t without awareness of how her personality and the things she said and did hurt others (myself included), and she was a very smart woman academically and creatively. When I told her that something she did or said hurt me, she didn’t say “I’m sorry. I will try not to do it again”. No, she would say, “that’s just how I am. You know with what my dad did to me”. Yes, I knew that. I also knew he wasn’t currently doing that her; she was no longer a victim, she was just choosing to continue to wear the victim cloak as an excuse not to alter her adult behaviour. Finally, it hurt me too much to continue to be her friend when she found it easier to say “this is how I am” than to alter her behaviour to prevent hurting those that were simply trying to be a good friend to her.

Sunday, April 1, 2012

On making "the unhappy" happy - Part 2/2

Of the war veterans I meet with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression, do you know what they value most in their lives? Not finding a “cure” for PTSD and depression, but just appreciating and being able to be with the people in their lives. They accept very courageously – not cowardly – the goals of treatment of these disorders: minimizing symptoms, moving forward from the last exacerbation, and decreasing the number of further exacerbations. They don’t seek a cure, though of course if it were feasible, they’d pay any price to have it. But why fight futile battles? So, I say again that they very courageously choose to expend their energies on the things that matter instead: love, productivity, enjoyment. But before you assume that I am making a claim such as “there is no cure for depression”, let me clarify that that is not the broad statement that I am making.

I used to think, naively, that once I fell in love, once someone loved me and I had someone to share my life with, I’d be happy. I wondered why the people I met who had the things that I thought would bring me happiness weren’t happy. How could they be depressed when they had a partner, children, a job they didn’t hate, generally good physical health, etc.? Why hadn’t the love they had in their loves not cured their depression? Because lack of love didn’t bring about the depression, nothing that was correctable did. Yes, they had love; but completely unrelatedly they also had a mental disorder. Finally I realized why people give flowers to sick relatives in hospital: the flower isn’t meant to “cure” the illness, just make it more tolerable by giving you that warm feeling inside that you’re not alone and reminding you that people care about you.

In persons who have become depressed or suffering PTSD as a result of some psychological social trauma, there is nothing in this world that can erase the memories and/or the cognitive processes that get programmed into your brain. Remarkably, though, a human being can go about their lives being perfectly functional and socially involved despite these demons we carry around in our head. When you have a chronic depression or PTSD of this kind, the best you can wish for is not being “cured”, but having people around you who understand you and stick with you on the journey. Not even “love” can erase the inner hell we experience with these mental disorders, but love can motivate the people around us to give us the all vital support and understanding. Conversely, if you find yourself in a relationship with a person who has depression or PTSD or a similar complaint, you will only hurt yourself by believing that your role is to bring about “cure”; it’s not. Your role is no different to that of anyone else who ever loved: to love, to give (including understanding), to receive, and to share life together.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

On making "the unhappy" happy - Part 1/2

One thing that took me a while to understand when I was younger is that “love”, or having a romantic relationship, doesn’t cure everything. In fairy tales, people fall in love and love rids you of physical “ugliness”, of having an evil heart, of disease and death, of financial poverty, of social oppression, of emotional and physical abuse, of low self-esteem, of disability, and of every negative thing that can happen to a human being. And don’t get me wrong, I like those stories as much as anyone else, and I'm also aware they are often metaphors for what love can actually achieve. Essentially love, being in love, being loved, loving, discovering love, etc. has the effect of giving human beings courage to believe in their own strength and to take risks. The greatest motivator for positive change and the strength to bring about that change is love. Love can conquer all…

The second most difficult thing for a human being to do is to bring about change in this world. The single most difficult thing in this life for us to do is to bring about change in ourselves. Love is supposed to make all things possible, right? That’s what the fairy tales tell us. That is what we have learnt personally from life. I still believe this is true. But there is one scenario unique to human beings I find particularly interesting when considering all that love can do.

Depression and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) result in unique states of mind where the “enemy” and the “villain” that we fight everyday lives exclusively within our hearts and minds. He may have been created by exposure to psychologically trauma or neurobiochemical imbalances or social oppression and abuse, or any of a myriad of negative human experiences. Yet the outcome of these situations are so common that someone has been able to make lists of the cognitive effects that result. They are described commonly in books and medical and scientific literature and classified into categories that receive the names of “mood disorders”. Depression, anxiety, and PTSD are very common diagnoses given to the people who suffer the effects of having these internal enemies to fight; the low mood, the lack of self-esteem, the sense of worthlessness, the compulsion to self-harm, the feelings of inability to better one’s own situation, and the inability to envision a future different to the inner world they seem trapped in.

I have seen many patients with PTSD, mainly war veterans, but all survivors of some sort of abuse or extremes of human experience. These people have lived through horrible things – and survived! If anybody can be called strong and honorable, it is them. Yet, they often are the first to believe they don’t deserve to be alive or to have good things in life. Bullets kill many soldiers in combat; depression and PTSD kills way too many survivors. People don’t choose to suffer depression, anxiety, or PTSD, the same way none of us choose to voluntarily suffer. And the worst part is that with these psychiatric complaints, you also can’t choose to “just snap out of it”. The goals of treatment in these disorders are not aimed at cure, but at managing symptoms, learning new ways to process information to help stop triggering these inner beasts, and minimizing the number of exacerbations. Of course, there are many ways we go about doing this (medication, psychotherapy, self-directed education, meditation, etc.), but generally there’s no way to completely cure these problems.

But wait, what about love? Doesn’t love “conquer ALL? Doesn’t love give you strength, courage, motivation, hope, etc. to achieve anything in life – even to change the world? The thing with depression, PTSD, and other psychiatric complaints is that the thing to conquer lies within. But love should be able to help you achieve even that, right? Isn’t love also able to change a human being? I used to believe just that.

Sunday, July 24, 2011

On the military and PTSD

There’s something I have wanted to discuss for a little while now but didn’t feel quite ‘qualified’ to. In fact the other reason I hesitated was because I was unsure of my future career direction/choices. It is a comment about the military, or more specifically I should say it is about post-traumatic stress disorder in ex-military persons.

What do I know about the military? Actually, having always been a civilian and having no family members with military or political pursuits, you could say I know nothing about it. Even growing up during the course of a civil war of the kind South and Central America was famous for in the 1980s, my own family was always politically neutral and non-participant. But I admit I do have a very privileged position in my job where people often share with me their stories – and don’t we all have our own war stories to tell!

Now, I won’t violate the trust gifted to me by the men / patients who have told me their stories, but I don’t even need to because the themes of their stories are all so similar. At some point in their journey they have come across me for very simple reasons, for something so banal as to re-prescribe them a certain medication. Usually they will tell me that they have been on some medication for years and just need to continue it, they are content with it, and they need it. And the types of medications they are on are pills for insomnia, for anxiety, to help deal with substance dependency, for depression, for psychosis – essentially medications to help them deal with negative thoughts and noxious mental states. I have previously discussed how men in particular are rarely keen to take psychotropic medications because of some concept of misplaced pride, and yet here I encounter men who are almost desperate to continue on these medications. Do you know what the difference often is? These are men who have seen hell, it lives in their thoughts and memories – they are the men who have been in military combat. These are not weak or desperate men, on the contrary; these are the men every country calls their “heroes”!

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is not a new concept nor is it specifically related to military service. Basically it describes a negative mental state that occurs after a person has suffered any traumatic experience. They will often re-experience the negative emotions experienced at the time of the event; often accompanied with vivid recollections of the event itself also. They will feel fear, panic, pain, hypervigilance, etc., exactly as they once did, and often this will be unaffected by the time that has elapsed since the initial event. The initial event can be any traumatic experience, and it is different for each individual with PTSD. Having said that, there are few things in life quite akin to active military service life. And you know what kind of people go into the military? All kinds.

The men I’ve met who tell me their stories almost invariably say ‘I wish I had known’. They wish that someone had told them about the nightmares every night, the hypervigilance and anxiety that denies them enjoying even simple things like just walking down the street without feeling on edge as they once did fearing they would be shot, etc. They wish that someone had told them that joining the military wouldn’t just be a way to secure employment training, to learn self-discipline, to defend and serve one’s country, to procure excitement, or the other variety of reasons a person may join military service. The disenchantment comes when the brave men taking life-and-death risks consider that they were deceived by a sin of omission. And more than disenchantment is the reality that few tasks in this life are as psychologically-endangering as the tasks encountered in warfare.

Of course, the military is possibly the best institution at training personnel in a variety of tasks, and their personnel learn how to “do their jobs” effortlessly. However, how many other jobs are there where you are personally in charge in deciding whether the person standing in front of your weapon will live or die, or that the chances of you killing someone are about the same as those of getting yourself killed, or seeing other human beings (adults, children, civilian, enemies, comrades) been purposely injured with weapons / things that were specifically designed with the intent to harm others? My job is not that stressful; I’d dare say very few other people’s are too. There's no way of estimating which types of events will be psychologically-traumatic to a person - but you can almost be sure that the kind of tasks encountered in military service are quite unique and should at least come with a forewarning.

And that is what these men wish they had been told; that’s why a lot of them become disenfranchised with the whole institution. A lot of these men feel that they have been treated not as men, not as humans, but as “things”, as these commodities that shoot the guns, as if they were merely an extension of the firearms themselves and not human beings with thoughts and emotions and brains that capture moments and memories for years to come. They wish they had known that. It’s a shame we do this to our “heroes”. It’s a shame we feel the need to go to war at all or that those few in charge of making national decisions send others to “represent” them; but if we must fight, I dare to propose that we are at least kind enough to those on our side.