Sunday, October 7, 2012

On camaraderie


The rape and death of Jill Meagher in the last fortnight has brought to our attention some things we take for granted in Australia: that it’s not safe in the streets late at night when you’re walking home on your own, especially if you’re a woman. Now, lets assume that we have only just realised this, what now? Yes, we could focus in about how unfair it is that a bad person went and hurt an innocent woman, or focus in about Australia become more unsafe than we previously thought it was. But I wonder if this realisation could in fact serve to inspire positive change, and in fact inspire something that becomes ingrained into our culture and our human social conscience: camaraderie.

When we realised that climbing mountains was dangerous, we went on to recommend spotters. We have spotters when we bench-press weights. We recommend hiking partners. Essentially most activities and sports that have an inherent sense of danger in it make use of the “buddy system”, where one or more people in a group mutually monitor and assist each other. Now, in some cultures the concept of mutually caring and helping the other doesn’t need a name, it is a social expectation. Looking after and caring about and for our friends is a social responsibility most people take on themselves even if they weren’t directly taught it by schools or families. But perhaps the time has come for us to be actively teaching this concept, maybe even as a (social) health promotion strategy.

There are some places in the world that have a higher incidence of crime than others, but even in the “safest” of places, there are still times when crime is more likely to occur than others. A lot of violent crimes happen at night. A lot of crime occurs where they are lots of people gathered. A lot of crime occurs in the context of alcohol or drugs… And so finally back to why Jill Meagher’s tragic story made me think of all this. Of course she did not deserve what happened to her. And of course none of the friends she went out with did anything wrong; they only did what seemed normal to them. And my proposition is that we as a society promote a new kind of normal. Her friends may have offered to take her home and she may politely refused, but rather than place blame on anyone other than the criminal that killed her, I propose we learn from this story and make some changes to prevent other people suffering the same fate as this woman. Lets make camaraderie as common as going out and having a fun time with your friends. Lets promote a social responsibility amongst people, friends we go out for a drink and a laugh with at least. Have it as a rule, even if it’s no longer an instinct in our society, that we care for the people we hang out with when we go out.  That we care from the minute they leave to go hang out with us, and that we care enough also to ensure they get back home safely.

Sunday, September 9, 2012

On anxiety in medicine

One thing we don't often talk about but which keeps so many people back from their lives is anxiety. I mean, of course, not the anxiety we all feel at understandably threatening or fearful situations; I mean anxiety which affects the way we live our lives, how we express ourselves, how we work, and our health. The best way someone explained anxiety to me is like asthma: your body is responding to a fairly harmless substance as if were something extremely dangerous; your body launches a response aimed at this harmless thing and the response itself hurts your body more than the harmless thing ever could!

Imagine a military battalion being on edge awaiting for an enemy strike. Suddenly a white sheet of paper gets flown into your team's territory, the area you're meant to be protecting. The area has been quite for so long, peace was declared years ago, but your troops remained on guard as if it was still in the midst of war. When the harmless piece of paper gets flown into your troop's protected area, no one knows what's going on and no one has time to think it through. Instinct kicks in. Fire!!! The troops launch an attack. Bullets go out, grenades, bombs, all and every weapon available is used. Eventually everything goes quite and you evaluate the damage: there's giant craters and fires burning throughout your own territory and your team's supplies are exhausted. What to do now? You restock your supplies (this costs your government money, time, and effort). You rebuild the areas of your territory that were damaged, and as you do so you curse that stupid piece of paper that brought all this about. You hate him now... Then one day another piece of paper will enter your territory again. And guess what? You will do exactly the same thing! You've come to believe that the enemy IS that piece of paper. The reality is that the real enemy is that jerk who let your troops keep believing there was still a fervent war going on, and the fact that you have now forgotten to think and evaluate each threat as it arises and are acting purely on instinct.

Anxiety works exactly the same way. The reason it arose was probably no fault of your own: you've probably lived through a war that required you to be on edge all the time. But now what? The circumstances changed and so must your thinking, otherwise you risk causing your own self more harm than the anxiety/worry/fear is worth.

In my job I meet a lot of people who give up on their own health due to anxiety. Sure, there are sometimes when I see the bravest of patients who present to me asking specifically for help to deal with the anxiety which they've realized is destroying their lives. I'm not talking about those people - they've already done the hardest part: they recognize their problem and have sought help for it. These people have victory guaranteed because they've already overcome the greatest obstacle! The people I am, however, wanting to discuss is those who still cannot identify their problem and believe their ill health is due to bad doctors, bad medicines, bad surgical procedures, etc.

Sometimes I see patients who refuse surgery for, for example, skin cancer. Why might they do that assuming they already know that cancer is a bad thing and they don't want to have it? Because the plastic surgeon who would remove the skin cancer from his face was a bastard and he wants nothing to do with him. Ok, so I suggest another surgeon. The second (and later third and fourth) is also a bastard! Wait, wait, wait, what's going on? Eventually I find out that the patient is really terrified of having surgery on his face - and until he gets over his fear of facial disfigurement every surgeon will keep being a bastard! I've seen the same time and time again with patients who have gynaecological problems, gastroenterological problems, cardiological problems, haematological and almost every other type of medical problem. I've had specialists ask that I please re-refer patients after they've had psychotherapy to deal with their anxiety. It ends up delaying treatment, and some patients go on to refuse treatment altogether.

What can I do? Many patients you just can't convince that it's not that every doctor is a bastard or has mistreated them. You can ask the questions and have the evidence right in front of them that this person has a debilitating anxiety problem but same as you can bring a horse to water but can't make him drink it, you just can't help those who refuse to acknowledge their greatest problem. What I sometimes do is tell my patients about these troubled army troops that keep attacking benign enemies and end up causing themselves greater harm than the "enemy" ever could. Do you think these troops might benefit from some retraining to help them better evaluate the enemy and launch and adequate response when it's due? Yes? I'd like to do the same for you, and I know just the person to help you with some retraining. This person's role is called a psychologist. Seeing him is not a sign of weakness but rather about redirecting your strengths where they're actually needed.

It is always such a shame to see people walk away with gynaecological cancers, thyroid cancers, valvular heart disease, severe renal failure, etc. who keep telling me that they'd rather die than see another horrible specialist. What I hear is 'I'd rather die than deal with my anxiety'. It's such a shame.

Sunday, September 2, 2012

On "the boat people"


Someone asked me the other day what I think about refugees, specifically the illegal immigrants that enter Australia on boats and are intercepted by Australian authorities. These last specifiers are important because they make this situation particularly unique. It’s no secret, and I consider this absolutely nothing to be ashamed about, that I entered Australia as a refugee from a war-torn country. I, however, find it difficult to form an opinion about the so-called “boat people” given that my family and I all entered the country legally on a comfortable passenger plane, were granted permanent resident status immediately on arrival, were escorted from the airport to a furnished and fully-stocked home in inner-city Brisbane, and received so much governmental support with negotiating a new country and a new language. The illegal immigrants I was asked about, although both refugees, are in a such completely different scenario that I find it personally hard to put myself in their shoes… And yet, so many people who are so much less qualified than even myself find it too easy to comment on “the boat people”.

A colleague once asked ‘why don’t illegal refugees from south-east Asia and other countries do what people from wealthier countries do?’ You know, just buy a plane ticket and come to Australia on tourist visas which they can then overstay and support themselves and escape the authorities however best they can. She suggested this would solve the issue of the Australian government having to process these illegal immigrants’ after-arrival applications to remain in Australia as refugees. Then Australian taxpayer’s money also wouldn’t be “wasted” on arresting and then housing refugees in detention centres, etc. Well, if you’re a citizen of certain countries, it’s actually quite difficult to get a tourist visa to Australia to overstay, and thus getting on a boat for illegal migration is much cheaper and easier despite all its inherent dangers. Well, this colleague suggested, why don’t the boats filled with illegal immigrants just get turned away or their passengers put on planes back to their own countries of origin before their stories/reasons for migration are heard. The reason for that is that would give the Australian government a bad human rights record… Oh yeah, it might actually be a violation of human rights.

So what do I know about refugees? I know that it must be a difficult decision to make to migrate to a country where the only certainty is that it’s not your own country (ideally for the better). When my family lived in El Salvador, people were migrating illegally into the surrounding countries, mostly northbound to the U.S.A. Around the time we left for Australia, the majority of people migrating illegally into the U.S.A. were leaving for the same reasons we were: seeking refuge from the hardships of war, the threats of death, and the intense poverty. Only a very very small minority were leaving “just for the hell of it”, and I believe perhaps no-one migrated illegally with the intention of hurting North-American citizens on their arrival. I also believe these broad categories/reasons remain true of all people who choose to migrate into another country. Why did my family migrate legally when others chose to do it illegally? Because we could. Why did others do it illegally when they could have done what my family did? Fear, lack of knowledge, I don’t know. I just don’t know. And I think that that’s the thing, that it is extremely hard to even imagine what it takes a human being to go through to make the choice where they consider it a lesser danger to hand over non-refundable money to an illegal human trafficker in order to board a shabby boat for a rough sea journey to a place you’ve never been to that speaks a language you don’t understand. How horrible must the other options have been?!

How do I feel about the “boat people”? A great curiosity to know their stories. And a wish that no person in this world had to suffer the hardships that lead most people to seek refuge in another country.

Sunday, August 26, 2012

On the things we think about


When I was a kid (truthfully, until recently), I sometimes asked my mum what she was thinking about. I always thought she was lying when she’d say “nothing in particular” or “what I need to buy from the store” or “what I will cook for dinner”, etc. The thing is that I would always be preoccupied with thinking about other things, things with little direct connection to my life, things like what it must it have been like to describe and name a new illness such a AIDS or (even tuberculosis if you were Robert Koch), why does it matter so much to people whether their religious beliefs will be proven right or wrong after death if they’re dead anyway when they see the definitive truth, etc. I wondered why mum never told me that she would think of things like this. Surely, I thought, everyone has abstract thought they dedicate time to. Why would mum not tell me what her “other” non-mundane thoughts were about? Surely a person has more than everyday-survival thoughts, right?

In the last few weeks, due to some difficulties that have affected my family, I have ended up becoming a guardian for my teenage nephew. And you know what? I have finally come to understand that my mum was not lying to me; she was just too busy being a parent to me and my four siblings to have time for non-mundane thought! I have in the last few weeks found myself actually thinking about and planning things that I would normally have left until the last minute, the boring stuff, the mundane stuff: what would be appropriate meals, what would be appropriate discipline, what are appropriate expectations, etc. It really does take up time to be thinking, more so because of my inexperience at this. Yet in a way it is also, I think, a blessing because having someone depend on you forces you to return the centre of Urie Bronfenbrenner’s ecological systems theory of human development. Sometimes a person can spend so much time thinking about how to change the world, how to change the future, about how things of the world should be, that you can forget that changing the world starts at home, with families, with ourselves. 


Sunday, August 12, 2012

On saying the right thing


Just a very quick blog today on things I’ve realised over the years about what to say in certain situations. The times I’m talking about are when someone is crying or sad; when someone is mourning; when someone is in trouble and worried; and pretty much any other time you’ve thought “I don’t know what to say”. The problem is that though we think there is a ‘right’ thing to say, the real answer is that these are the times when we don’t need to say anything at all. The only thing you need to be doing when you find yourself in a situation where you don’t know what to say is to not say anything at all and just listen. Yes, really listen. Pay attention, become interested, and if you must say anything, then say that which you feel, “I don’t know what to say”.

Sunday, August 5, 2012

On excuses, reasons, and choice


I met someone some time ago who had some personality features I didn’t quite like. We were close for a time and so I told her that some of the things she did bothered and sometimes even hurt me. She told me that it was all because that’s just how she was, that that’s how she had turned out after been raped as a teenager by her father. Of course, that is a terrible thing to happen to anyone and I know it takes a lot of courage to tell your own story. And, of course, I also realise that childhood sexual abuse really does mess you up in so many ways! The strangeness of this particular situation was that this friend said to me fairly often “that’s just how I am” and reminded me about her father. I knew; I wasn’t going to forget what she had told me – it was something deeply serious! However, after so many times that she told me that that’s how she is and it’s due to the childhood sexual abuse she had suffered, I remembered that she wasn’t the only person this had happened to. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a very sad and disturbing thing and every single person this happens to will experience it differently and will be affected differently by it in the long-term. However, I felt that with me she was using it as an excuse for her behaviour so as to avoid apology, or – God forbid – change.

I have known a very many people who have been sexually abused as children and not everyone was as mean as this ‘friend’ was to me; they weren’t obligated to be mean by reason of their terrible experiences. When I remembered this, and at the last straw with this friend, I walked away from it all. Yes, I know that people with histories of abuse in childhood are more likely to have a personality disorder in adulthood than those who never had those experiences. And yet I also believe in the human potential for change. I know that you can take away every choice from a child when he is abused. I also know that at some point a child becomes and adult and all adults have the choice to continue to be victims to the past or to progress from there. It’s a choice. My friend wasn’t without awareness of how her personality and the things she said and did hurt others (myself included), and she was a very smart woman academically and creatively. When I told her that something she did or said hurt me, she didn’t say “I’m sorry. I will try not to do it again”. No, she would say, “that’s just how I am. You know with what my dad did to me”. Yes, I knew that. I also knew he wasn’t currently doing that her; she was no longer a victim, she was just choosing to continue to wear the victim cloak as an excuse not to alter her adult behaviour. Finally, it hurt me too much to continue to be her friend when she found it easier to say “this is how I am” than to alter her behaviour to prevent hurting those that were simply trying to be a good friend to her.

Sunday, July 29, 2012

On religion and mental illness


Karl Marx, a 19th century philosopher, told us that religion “is the opium of the people”. He meant not that it makes you believe things that aren’t real and see things that aren’t there, but that it has the soothing and calming effects opium has on the human mind in amongst the turbulence of what goes on in the real world. So then the question becomes, what is real? Is God real? Actually, it’s not what I intend on discussing here, but rather an anecdotal relationship I have noted between those with mental illness and their religious beliefs.

I may have discussed it earlier, but there was the story that was told to me by a neuroscience professor: There was once a very devout Christian religious minister who developed a brain tumour. The tumour affected this man’s thinking capacity, his cognitive function, and interestingly it made him unable to understand or believe in a non-physical, abstract, concept such as God. He lost his faith not because he was disappointed in God, but because the part of his brain related to religious faith was damaged! My professor took this as hard evidence that God and religious faith is nothing more than a human cognitive construct and in fact there is no God out there in wherever a person believes he is. Now, that is a pretty good deduction, but perhaps a bit premature. For example, if the antenna broke on my TV and I could no longer receive the signals that transmit my favourite shows, would I be right in concluding that in fact the television channels never existed in the first place or even that they have stopped transmitting the moment my antenna broke?

The opposite to the scenario proposed by my university professor could also happen. Some people with epilepsy and even those with migraines can experience an “aura” before an attack. The aura is different for everyone and some will suddenly experience a particular taste on their tongue, a music in their ears, a vision in their sight, a smell in their nose, etc. – yet these sensations are all originating from brain activity, not the organs they appear to be coming from. There are the rare people who experience very complex auras, things like seeing a halo-like figure of a person who resembles how a religious figure is depicted in art, or who hear a voice like that of a relative who is now dead. Of course, in the medical world we may call them auras or a sign of temporal lobe epilepsy or aberrant brain activity, but then other people may call them religious experiences. I won’t even try to conclude anything from that for anyone, but it is an interesting thought.

A quote often attributed to Robert M. Pirsig, a writer and philosopher, is “When one person suffers from a delusion it is called insanity. When many people suffer from a delusion it is called Religion”. As a medical student doing a post in a psychiatric ward, I first started to notice how a large number of patients’ delusions revolved around God and other religious concepts. As an example, a person might believe that electricity is controlled by the devil and every time you plug in an appliance to a powerpoint then that lets the devil into your house. Or she may be obsessed with keeping her clothes clean all the time and protects them from being invaded by others and germs and other such things because she has read some scripture in the bible about guarding your heart and wearing the armour (of faith) and has taken her armour to be her clothes and she guards it by standing in the same spot for hours on end watching out that no one or nothing gets to it. Others have believed they are carrying the devil’s child in their pregnant bellies as foretold by some scripture they have read/misread somewhere. Or that the people putting thoughts in their heads are either angels or demons or God himself and that they must heed their ministry of whatever they’re been instructed to do… These people, however, have ended up in mental hospitals because what they’ve done or attempted to do has posed a threat of physical damage to themselves or others. Generally that is why they’re considered “crazy” and not just a founder (or follower) of a religion with those beliefs.

Now, I will very openly admit to being a Christian; one who believes things about God and other divine creatures that neither I or anyone anywhere on Earth currently has ever seen with human eyes. Yet I also remain curious about the relationship between religious belief and mental illness, especially when it comes to psychosis. Consider a person who has never had any religious inclination at all; perhaps someone the opposite of the religious minister of my neuroscience professor’s story. Suddenly, and I mean within a space of a few days, this person starts to believe that he can speak in a language new to him but that isn’t a language of this world or of a fictional book or film and can be understood by no one of this world. To all human ears he appears to just be making sounds with his mouth. Along with this “speaking in tongues”, he believes that God is giving him dreams that have special meaning about the past, present, and future. He also believes that he has been chosen by God and can exert God’s will of healing by merely touching the infirm of body and/or spirit. Unfortunately, due to his unique position before God, he believes that the devil (God’s enemy) is trying to hurt him. To minimize the hurt from the devil, he may engage in ritualistic behaviours such as rocking back and forth in his chair, hitting his head against the wall, or cutting himself to let out the bad energies. His new life revolves around speaking and singing about God and his newfound faith whenever he can and to whomever is around, sometimes even when no one is around… A psychiatrist may diagnose this man with a delusional disorder. Someone else may say ‘here’s a new member of the Pentecostal church who has reached enlightenment’.

Lastly, I will leave you with a comical quote by George Carlin that I found amusing:
“Religion has convinced people that there's an invisible man living in the sky, who watches everything you do every minute of every day. And the invisible man has a list of ten specific things he doesn't want you to do. And if you do any of these things, he will send you to a special place, of burning and fire and smoke and torture and anguish for you to live forever, and suffer, and suffer, and burn, and scream, until the end of time. But he loves you. He loves you. He loves you and he needs money.”