Sunday, March 31, 2013
A prison story
I haven’t written in a few weeks. Frustration, anxiety, pesky illnesses, and new passions really take a toll on you. I still feel partly censored in what I can divulge here, so let me tell you about the new passion I’m trying to develop. I’m learning to play guitar. And more than learning to play it, I want to know everything about them, about music, and just really feel my blood pulsate differently when I think of it. I have even bought an electric guitar I’m taking apart, modifying, and (hopefully) put back together again. I love the feeling it gives me to be in control of such a versatile instrument. Just thinking about it gives me a buzz…
Another passion of mine is humanity, yet I say that more in the Fyodor Dostoevsky sense of “The more I love humanity in general, the less I love man in particular”. I like watching prison documentaries for the stories about a different version of humanity you may or may not encounter every day. And there is one story that keeps bouncing around in my head which I would like to share because I found it so intriguing.
There’s this prisoner serving a sentence that will mean he spends the rest of his life in prison with no possibility of parole. He starts off by telling the story of how he has been a criminal for a very long time. He was selling drugs, stealing, using drugs, etc. He had been in and out of prison since he was a teenager until eventually he managed to score his final life-long sentence.
Anyhow, while he was in prison, his son got arrested for murder. At one point the son was in the jail next to the prison his father was in. What the prisoner’s son and some other men had done was they killed someone, and for that crime they were up for the death penalty. But the son's lawyers organized for his father to testify at his son’s trial, saying how he gave a bad example to him, and that he wasn't there to teach him right because he was always in and out of prison or high and drunk as the son was growing up. Also, the family was very poor because the father wasn’t able to work because of his criminal lifestyle, drug and alcohol abuse, etc. The co-defendants in the son’s murder trial didn’t have the opportunity to have their sentenced reduced from the death penalty because their fathers weren’t in prison.
When the son's trial date came up, the lawyers thought they'd do a charitable act by both father and son and organized to pick them up in the same prison van so they could ride together to the courthouse. In the prison van, the guards and lawyers were all feeling very warm and fuzzy that they had granted this father and son to sit together even for a short trip (though no one knows who specifically asked for this). While in the prison van, the son held his father’s hand through the handcuffs behind their backs. He was grateful to his father for helping get him off death row. Afterwards everyone who had helped organized this great gesture between father and son, were feeling really good about themselves.
Then someone asked the father if he was happy to see his son, and was he excited to be able to help him out, etc. The father answered and said he'd never ever felt worse in his life! He said never had he felt more ashamed and like an absolute worthless human being. He had never felt as low as he felt that day. He said he was disgusted at himself; truly hated himself for the experience. He said he would have preferred never to have seen or heard or touched his son again in his life than to see him like that: in the back of a prison van while up for the death penalty for the disgusting crime he had committed. He said never had he felt like the worst father and the worst person in the world than that day. He said to him that it felt like it was his own death sentence that day, knowing he had failed as a human being. That day he truly repented of all his own wrongdoing and he wished he had never been born so at to give life to someone like or worse than him, even if he was his own blood.
He cried at how embarrassed of himself as a human being he was, and the fact that people thought of him as a hero or a good man for having gotten his son off death row. (Yes, the son had his sentence reduced to life without the possibility of parole.)
Wow, this story touched me very much and I can’t even really explain why.
Sunday, March 3, 2013
The goals and business of general practice
In the last week I have been involved in the recruitment of a new nurse to the primary care clinic I’ve been working in. (And I should note that the terms general practice, general medicine, and primary care, are been interchangeably here) I suggested that we ask applicants in the job interview what, in their opinion, are three goals of (private) general practice medicine. This is a question that potentially has dozens of answers! To patients, up to 95% of the time it is about helping them deal with immediate, though generally non-urgent, health problems. The rest of the time it is about preventing ill or worse health. To governments, the goals of general practice medicine are to keep people healthy so that they utilize less government-funded health resources. General practice is meant to keep patients out of hospitals. But what are the goals of primary care medicine if you happen to work in a primary care clinic? I think that if you understand the way the business of general practice, the goals of general practice are fairly straightforward - from a business perspective, because this is an industry just like many others.
How does general practice work? Well, patients require a
service so they contact the practice’s administration staff to book this
service: a medical review with a doctor. Booking appointments is just one of
the tasks of the admin staff, and their tasks are fundamental to the proper and
smooth running of the practice as a business and also in optimizing the
clinical interaction between the patient and the doctor. The doctor takes the
patient’s clinical history and requests investigations and treats their
condition, etc. To do this more efficiently and effectively, they often enlist
the help of the practice nurse. The nurse has a very important part in the
running of the practice too. They are there to advocate for the patient, to
help carry out a lot of the preventative activities related to medical
practice, they administer medications and immunisations, they perform some of
the tests the doctor needs to help clarify the patient’s diagnosis, etc. They
do all this in the background so the doctor doesn’t need to do it herself – and
in this time the doctor may see another patient or take care of another
clinical activity. That’s it. At the end, the patient pays one fee to cover the
cost of seeing the doctor, the nurse, and having administration staff assist
them.
![]() |
| How General Practice Works |
Now, how does the money side of general practice work? There
is one source of money coming into the practice: patients. That’s right, the
only income-generating activity in general practice occurs in the interaction
between the doctor and the patient in that room. For example, talking to the
receptionist doesn’t attract a fee (as a patient you could theoretically come
in and talk to one all day and she can’t bill you for anything as she hasn’t
sold you anything).
![]() |
| Where the money in General Practice comes from. |
What then? Well, the money generated by the doctor’s fees is
pooled and is meant to cover the cost of paying the practice’s staff, the
building rental fees, insurance costs, medical and non-medical equipment costs,
etc. And that exactly is why it is important for practice managers, for
administration staff, and for nurses to help doctors see more patients and to
see them efficiently and effectively.
![]() |
| Where the money in General Practice goes to. |
So what are the business goals of general practice? I
believe they are so closely related to the duties of general practice that you
could be forgiven for mistaking them. The first priority of (any) medical
practice are the patients. Keeping them well, that is giving them what they pay
us for (assistance with health problems), is and needs to be the first goal.
The second goal is to optimize the interaction between the patient and the
doctor; the “service” being sold. It is the task of everyone working alongside
the doctor to make sure this happens well, smoothly, and in a time-efficient
manner. The third priority is to the community in which we work. This makes
sense not just in a humanistic ideal but because general practice, as opposed
to other medical specialties, often deals with people who are well and healthy
– and who want to remain that way! Healthy patients don’t attend cardiologists,
for example, to prevent cardiac disease. No, they would go see the cardiologist
once cardiac disease is diagnosed or suspected and they need secondary
prevention or treatment. But general practice does see well people for this and
many other preventative activities.
It makes so much sense from a business point of view to
fulfil our duties in general practice, that is to patients, to the staff, and
to our community. Patients that are well-cared for and feel/know that they are
being prioritised want to continue using that service. If you optimise the
doctor-patient interaction (in business terms: time), you make the business more
profitable. And if you cater to the local community, that community gets to
know and trust your service and seek it out amongst the other dozens of similar
practices around. What is there to lose by fulfilling the duties of our jobs in
general practice, really?
Sunday, February 17, 2013
On responsibility
I remember one of the greatest lessons taught to me both at home and at school was about responsibility. It was such a good trait in a person that even if you owned up to wrong-doing, there would be an incentive for the admission (e.g. reduced punishment). I wonder now what happened to make taking responsibility for almost anything such a dirty affair.
Do you know when people are quick to claim responsibility for things? When things go right! Politicians, for example, are a great at speaking of their triumphs in war, claiming they achieved this or that target. For a moment it would be possible to convince yourself that Barack Obama was literally holding the firearm that killed Osama bin Laden, such was the claim that “we got him”. In science journals a string of names appear as the “researchers”, and if the discovery or finding is big news enough, the person giving the interview will be the person who runs the research institute or the head of the lab – not the little guy who actually did all the intellectual and physical work. Similarly in medicine, especially in teaching hospitals, the name of the consultant will always be quoted as the guy who did the surgery or who treated a patient’s complex medical problems – where in reality the consultant probably has never laid eyes on the patient. But I am, of course, talking about when things go right, the successes. The culture extends all the way to clinical records, as I have had to explain to patients in the past: “I know the information is about you, and it was collected and written by me, but it belongs neither to you or me apparently but to the person who lent me the pen and paper (or computer) with which I recorded the information”. Or at least this is what I have been told in the past by previous employers… Imagine if the same had been done to the great poets and writers of the past. Mark Twain would not have made a cent from the proceeds of the sale of Huckleberry Finn but the manufacturer of the pen and paper he wrote with would have made some very easy money!
Now, when things go wrong in medicine, it’s not the hospital’s or the clinic’s fault, it’s not the consultant’s fault – then it is all about the little guy. When competitions are won, a whole nation claims victory; but when they are lost, it’s the one competitor or team who is the loser. When corruption is uncovered, it is always said it was just one person’s fault, not the institution or the culture that drove him to it, etc. We have become very quick to deny responsibility for ourselves and distance ourselves from all negative events. Unfortunately, this has come to extend to our personal lives too.
If there is one thing I pride myself on is trying to be an understanding and non-judgemental human being. I have met people, though, who confuse taking responsibility with admitting fault, and therefore they refuse/avoid/delay taking responsibility at all. We are all shaped by our childhood experiences, past relationships, our genetics, formal and informal education, etc. All these things together shape how we are today. Now, one or more of those things may have been a profound traumatic negative experience that has gone on to shape us significantly – and maybe even negatively. As a result of that experience perhaps we become highly attuned to certain words people say (perhaps words bullies may have used) or to misinterpreting body language or we come to expect that certain words will be followed by physical abuse, etc. When you experienced those things before it was perhaps appropriate to retaliate or go on the defence. The thing is when you are no longer in that situation and you continue to react as if you were, that is when our own actions/defence become our offense. That is when we hurt ourselves more, or others too. Now, as I said, I can understand this and I can forgive this. No one is saying it is your fault you are the way you are; and it’s certainly not your fault those negative things may have happened to you (emotional or physical abuse, etc.), but it is each individual’s responsibility to decide whether they want to continue to be and act the same or to change. I see the person who refuses to change, who points out how it’s not their fault, who perhaps feels guilt but not motivation to change, as someone caught up in victimhood. And as I have stated many times before, we are not victims of our past but rather the creators of our own future. And trust me, there are still plenty of incentives out there for those that do stand up courageously and take responsibility.
Labels:
abuse,
human beings,
human relations,
love,
medicine,
relationships,
self-esteem,
trauma
Sunday, January 27, 2013
On global warming
I haven’t written in a little while because I have been quite busy with organising things for a change in job (location, not career) and also some personal difficulties which I won’t go into just yet. But I have managed to give myself 2 weeks off work to just settle the pace in the last few months, and I have been watching some mostly mind-numbing television but also some interesting stories. One that particularly surprised me was a debate on nuclear versus fossil fuel derived energy. Here’s the link if anyone is interested in watching it.
What I found particularly interesting about the debate on fossil fuels versus nuclear energy are the premises and assumptions the debate (for both sides) are founded on. You see, every debate argues that one “thing” is better than the opponent’s “thing”, but there is also common ground – there has to be. So one opponent may say, for example, “I’m trying to do the most just thing for everyone and this ‘thing’ I represent is better for justice than the thing that my opponent is backing. The other opponent goes and makes the same argument, but proposes his thing is better for justice. The debate is interesting and relevant because it focuses on a common ground: justice. And you know what I found interesting in this fossil-fuel vs. nuclear energy debate? That the common ground that both parties were intent on protecting was climate change. Yes, here were big energy industry representatives arguing that they wish to protect the environment, prevent further climate change / global warming, and therefore nuclear energy is bad. On the opposite side of the debate were nuclear energy proponents arguing that they wish to protect the environment, prevent further climate change / global warming, and therefore fossil-fuel energy is bad (and also that other non-fossil-fuel energies are non-viable). I was fascinated not by the points of argument each team debated, but that suddenly global warming and climate change was a given, not the point of argument itself. No one was debating whether climate change was real in and of itself!
In political and legislative forums, the existence of this concept of global warming is negated by representatives of the fossil fuel industry. Now, in a debate whether on whether nuclear energy or fossil fuel energy is worse, global warming and climate change is taken as a fact – and the people arguing these both these things are almost the same people. That is what I find quite interesting. Environmentalists get invited to these events to present the debate on behalf of nuclear power companies, mining companies, and “green energy” companies (which are usually owned by the mining companies themselves). Of course, for the sake of arguments such as this, all the types of energy companies claim to have one thing at heart: the environment. In reality we all know that thing at the heart of any company are monetary profits. I mean, that is exactly the reason why mining companies invest heavily in “green energy”: because if the market happens to shift and “green energy” becomes more profitable than fossil-fuel energy, then you want to be the guy that owns this market already...
It’s all nice and interesting, but now I’m more confused. Is global warming considered a real thing or not in Australian politics? If so, then what are we (including the energy industry and other big carbon emitters) doing about it? If not, why not if even the energy industry can at times concede that it is a real thing?
Labels:
environment,
global warming,
government,
money,
politics
Saturday, December 29, 2012
On loving
![]() |
| I must endure the presence of a few caterpillars if I wish to become acquainted with the butterflies |
I imagine – and, yes, I believe imagining is not enough –
that to be truly in love two people have to be really sure of themselves, of
their feelings, of their partner’s character, and of their partner’s feelings.
How else to do you put it all on the line like that? How do you accept such
vulnerability if not by having at least a substantial amount of trust in
someone else? It’s hard enough in this world to trust yourself (at least for
some of us), but then to trust someone else too – Wow! That to me is what I
have perhaps never experienced if I am now doubting whether I truly have known
love.
The one question that niggles at the back of the mind of
someone like me who has in the past believed that they were in love with
someone else is ‘is it reciprocated?’ And an even worse and even more troubling
question is ‘am I giving too much for what I can expect in return?’ I know,
right, we all are told that biblical/romantic story that true “love is
patient”, “love is kind”, “love is not selfish”, blah blah blah; so I should be
feeling ashamed for having just admitted that those questions do go through the
minds of so many of us, especially the majority of us who have been heartbroken
in the past. But love IS selfish and unkind and impatient; I believe it has to
be! For you to truly believe that the person whom you love is worthy of your
love, you have to believe that they are someone special. And yet you have to
convince yourself that they’re not so special so as to deserve someone better
than us mere mortals with all the flaws in ourselves of which we have full
comprehension. No, you have to be selfish and think, ‘yes, they’re special and
deserve the best in the world, but I don’t care about that because I desire
them to be mine’. There you go, that’s selfish! It’s selfish but I believe it’s
necessary, and admittedly it is the same concept that brings about the impulse
in us to better ourselves. We want to become that amazing person our own
“special person” deserves – and there’s nothing wrong with that!
Is there something wrong with wanting or expecting someone
to reciprocate our love? Oh yes, the biblical story again about giving
unselfishly and without expectation of getting something is return… Well, I
don’t believe it applies here. What’s the validity of loving someone if they
don’t love you back? That is NOT love. That is worship or idolatry or something
of that quality. It doesn’t console me to be loved by someone I don’t love in
return, and it doesn’t rejoice my heart either to love someone who doesn’t love
me in return (or whom I believe doesn’t). But besides wanting to be loved in
return, I want to be loved equally.
Equality in love; oh gosh, I wish I could believe again that
such a thing is possible. I mean, people get married all the time; it must be
possible to love like that, right? Right? I’m at a loss here. I want desperately
to believe it’s possible, but the evidence doesn’t convince me fully. Because I
have been heartbroken in the past, maybe even too many times, I find it hard to
ever imagine a time when I ask the question “am I giving too much?” and the
answer is no. More interestingly is I (and perhaps others in my situation too)
have never asked “am I giving too little?” I thought about this only a short
time ago. I had never asked myself that question; and at the same time I was
certain that almost 100% of the time I was
giving too much, without a doubt. But what if I’m not? What if I am giving too
little or what I give are only irrelevant things? Woah! That took some effort
to overcome my ego to just write that last sentence. I often think that the
things others are offering me are too little!
What would I give up for love? I’ve spoken of it; I’d
give money, my career, lesser dreams than love, my religion perhaps, etc. But
what won’t I give up? That is the more important question! Well, it would be
hard for me to give up my family, especially my mother. It’d be hard to give up
my desire to be a parent to a child during my lifetime. It would be hard for me
to commit murder or break other deep-seated morals I stand against. It would be
hard to give those things up for love, because it would be akin to abandoning
my true self. What have I to offer anyone if I lack even my own integrity, my
own character, my own self-respect? Sure, there is devotion and one can still
do good even without a grain of soul left in you, but that is not living to me.
Who would ask this of me? Who would expect I empty my soul in order to be with
them? Well, some people would say that this is exactly what the devil does: ask
for your soul even if there is nothing left in it. Could I love someone like
that? Could I expect to be loved by someone like that? And it sounds dramatic
when I put it in those terms, but you have to remember that the world we live
in isn’t too far from my analogy. Adolf Hitler had a wife who adored him and
loved him to the very last breath. Paedophiles often have wives who hide their
secrets for them, who sometimes even assist their partners in their crimes.
One day I would like to be in love, truly in love. I would
like to feel that my love is reciprocated, that it’s equalled, and that it is
worth both my and my partner’s sacrifices.
Labels:
human beings,
human relations,
love,
me,
relationships,
vanessa
Sunday, December 16, 2012
On the greatest lessons I've learnt
![]() |
| Me and my primary school teacher. She taught me my greatest lessons. |
In the last week, several events close to me and others
we’ve been able to witness through the media have made me think a lot about my
own mortality and what things we’d like to leave those close to us. Most people
assume this means monetary inheritance and other ephemeral things of that
nature. In my case, I was born without these things and so they are of little
importance to me. I got to thinking, however, of the legacies and the truly
valuable things I have acquired that I would love to leave to my offspring, my
peers, and to any and all who care to know of these things that Vanessa really
cherishes. So, below, I’ve written a list of the most important things taught
to me, or the greatest lessons I’ve learnt.
1. Education is the one thing that truly pits people as
equals.
Why is education important to me? Because it was important
to my mother, and it was important to her for her children to have it. My
mother has a primary school education but was smart enough to know that what
would keep her children out of these perpetual cycles of poverty that have
dominated my family and ancestors – and that was/is within the reach of most
people – is education. My family had always been peasants and servants, hard-working
people but with little possessions to their name. Our name was nothing
important; we are commoners. We didn’t have the money, the social or political
connections, or much else. But my mum made sure that she worked very hard to be
able to provide for her children not only food and shelter, but almost at an
equal importance, also education. She taught us that we had the same potential
to learn and succeed academically as any other person, even those with money or
connections or whatever other perceived advantage. Then this, and not the name
or money we didn’t have, would open our world up to as many opportunities as we
were willing to accept and work hard for.
2. The single greatest thing you can teach a person is a hunger
to know more, a lust to achieve more, and a passion for your subject matter.
Passionate people don’t know satiety, and they also never learn defeat.
Great teachers aren’t the people who taught Nobel Prize
winners the knowledge they used to achieve their success, but rather the ones
who were able to transfer to them a passion into the field of their success. Passion,
a burning insatiable desire, is the only antidote to failure.
3. “We are poor – not because of God”. No more effort is
required to aim high in life, to demand prosperity and abundance, than is
required to accept misery and poverty.
Two Napoleon Hill quotes. Why are they important to me?
Well, the first I’ve discussed previously so I won’t go into it again, but the
second took me a while to get my head around. It’s hard to be poor or to not
attain your dreams, right? But it’s really really hard work to get what you
want too. If you work hard, and I mean passionately and relentlessly hard, you
probably can become a famous movie actor, a celebrated artist, a professional
in a field with strict entry criteria and few spots for newcomers. It’s going
to take a lot of very very hard work! But what’s the alternative? The
alternative is actually equally hard. This is what blew my mind. It takes a lot out of you feeling crushed every day because you’re not working the job you’re
really keen for. If you’re poor, it is really really hard to do physical labour
to get just the bare minimum to feed yourself and go to bed hungry and know
that you have to wake up tomorrow to do the same thing again so you can go to
bed with a half-empty stomach the following night. It’s really very hard to be
poor. So if both roads are hard, and I am suggesting here that they are equally
hard, why not risk your pride and show some faith, and follow the path of your
dreams? I mean, the alternative is just as hard.
4. You don’t fail until you give up. Failure is experienced
only by those who when they experience defeat, stop trying. The only thing that
separates success and failure is the number of attempts.
5. Improbable does not mean impossible.
6. You miss every shot you don’t take.
7. Be willing to risk failure in order to succeed.
8. Every soldier dies a hero.
I believe the thing that holds human beings back more than
fear is pride. I will consider the last five points together as I believe they
are intrinsically linked. Often people list a dim statistic for success as an
excuse for not trying or for not going for the thing they really want. I always
ask these people, “So? Someone has to get it, so why can’t that someone be you?”
Oh yes, they tried that one time and they failed. Or they would try, but it’s
just going to be a waste of time and effort as they will most likely not
succeed. You know, because somehow these people believe they are fortune
tellers too! The one 100% fool-proof method to guarantee failure is not to try.
I mean, you can’t win the lottery if you don’t buy a ticket, right? So, as
small and as uncontrollable the probability of attaining your goal on the next
attempt is, it’s still greater than zero if you at least attempt it. So what if
you don’t succeed? You’re only one attempt closer if you’re courageous enough
to keep trying and don’t let that stupid pride convince you that lack of
success in an attempt means failure forever.
That last statement came to me rather unexpectedly one day when
I happened to be listening to the radio in my car to some news about a soldier’s
death. Some days you have to contemplate that you will die, and you may die soon
without warning. What if you died and you still had not achieved that one goal
you had dedicated your life to? Does that mean you’re a failure? Does that mean
you’re a loser? Well, think about soldiers. They literally risk their lives in
order to achieve an outcome: to defend from the enemy and to destroy an
attacking enemy. But sometimes soldiers die in battle, and when they die in
this way you could say they have failed in their goal. Now, do we consider
these soldiers who died in the line of fire as failures? No! We call them brave
and courageous and war heroes. Yes, they didn’t succeed in what they were
trying to achieve, but they weren’t failures because they died trying to
achieve that outcome. I believe that similarly, in civilian life, we don’t die
as failures if we died trying to achieve that one thing we really wanted.
9. Anger and hatred are the most successful ways to waste
energy and to keep our enemies in power. People may hurt you in the present by
some wrong action, but the anger and hatred we pay them well into the future is
how we continue to hurt ourselves on their behalf.
This is one I learnt from experience when I was about 20
years old. I was getting so run down, so upset all the time, feeling so much
anger and (I’m ashamed to admit it now) hatred towards one person. Now, this
person had stopped tormenting me years ago and yet I kept feeling all these
negative things towards them; they had probably forgotten I existed, and yet I
kept hating them. It really takes so much energy to remain angry and sad! One
day I realised this, that I must have been barely a speck of this person’s
world and that was so long ago, and I still kept dedicating so much of my life
to them, feeling for them, even if was hatred and anger. And I came to
realise that I had given them enough of my life. I closed my eyes one day and
said a prayer. I told them in my prayer that I forgive them, that I forgive
myself, and that I wanted to forget the whole experience and become me again
without traces or stains of their existence in my life. You know what? It was
the best thing I could have done for ME to make my life about myself and not
the people that have hurt me.
10. Money is the world’s most renewable resource. There’s no
glory in being the richest man in the graveyard.
Mark Bouris once said that in business you don’t want to
hire a man who has always produced a positive result, who has always managed to
make his company profit. You want to hire the man who has had nothing, possibly
being bankrupt due to his own mistakes – but that has managed to build himself
back up. Money has a way of always renewing itself, so it’s not worth all the
effort and value we place on losing it. Personally, I think we risk far too
many valuable things like relationships, health, and true happiness to attain
or maintain money. Eventually we will all die, and our deathbed it will
probably be more comforting to have your loved ones by your side rather than
the knowledge that in a bank somewhere there sits a big dollar figure associated
with your name.
11. Do unto others as you would like have done unto you.
Every religion and most human philosophies will rephrase
this in different words and attribute this concept to one of millions of
God-like figures. That’s irrelevant, but the concept is more about the
preservation of humankind, of our humanity, and of our own self-esteem. It
actually comes naturally to most human beings from a very young age, but later
it becomes a conscious choice of our own integrity. Mark de Moss defines integrity as, “Integrity is not what we do when it serves us. It is who we are in the
dark and how we treat people when it makes no difference to us”. That’s one
thing that would benefit anyone (and everyone) to learn, I think.
12. To be a man is to be responsible; to be ashamed of
miseries you did not cause; to be proud of your comrade’s victories; to be
aware, when setting one stone, that you are building a world.
Somewhere in the past century we all got so caught up in the
various human rights movements that a corrupted self-entitled attitude came to
develop from it and a lot of us came to forget about responsibility.
13. You have to tolerate the caterpillars if you want to see
the butterflies.
Another Antoine de Saint-Exupery quote. Life isn’t always
easy and it’s unreasonable to expect it to always be. Sometimes you just have
to stay focused on what’s coming or what you want to come next.
14. Let every occasion be a great occasion.
Yes, a lot of the things I’m sharing above are of course not
mine but things I’ve learnt from others. Some things I’ve learnt from
experience; most are out of a book called ‘Success through a Positive Mental
Attitude’, co-written by Napoleon Hill; some from my theological study; and
some are probably from Oprah or the Dr. Phil show! There’s no shame in how you
came to learn a thing, only that it is valuable to your own life somehow.
Labels:
education,
ethics,
family,
friendship,
happiness,
human beings,
human relations,
human rights,
Integrity,
positive thinking,
work
Sunday, December 9, 2012
On levels of evidence
A patient asked me the other day if I thought she was a crazy person for telling me she was going to disregard my advice on managing her high cholesterol and high blood pressure and go have a chat to her naturopath instead. I said no, that doesn’t offend me at all. Actually, it has nothing to do with me. I had explained to her the risks of untreated hypertension and hyperlipidemia and about how medications can help those, etc. etc. I had disclosed sufficient information for her to make an informed decision on her own health. She has a right to refuse treatment just as I had a duty to provide that information to her as her treating doctor. Medico-legally, I was in a defensible/safe area. Aside from that, though, did I think she was crazy for refusing well-advised medical opinion? Well, no. And this is what I told her.
You know, I believe in God. I believe in the Judeo-Christian version of God and in creationism. I’m comfortable in believing these stories that if you applied the scientific level of “proof” are actually quite laughable. So how do I get around holding such preposterous beliefs and still having some sort of pride in calling myself both a Christian and a scientist? I don’t apply the same level of proof or set of rules to all my beliefs. And yet, why do I believe the Christian and not the Islamic or Mosaic or Taoist or any other version of life philosophy? A whole heap of reasons! Probably because the country I grew up in had 99% of its population listed as catholic. Probably because my family is Christian. Probably because Christianity was all around me and the stories were told to me since I was very young. I was told from very early on also that the people who lived in my house were my siblings, my mum, etc. and I believed it. Even now I do not see the need to demand DNA-evidence to “prove” the story that these people are related to me. Similarly, I was told stories about God and Jesus and prophets, etc., and I am happy still to believe them. But what has all this got to do with my initial story about the lady who wanted to see the naturopath?
I’ve been trained in Western Medicine. I have a system in my mind with which I approach illness and human functioning. Briefly, I studied anatomy and physiology and pathophysiology so I believe 1) The body has these organ systems working together to make the body function in the environment, 2) The body is trying to stay “alive” and function properly as it’s default, 3) When the body is failing at functioning, it is because of an illness, 5) Illness is brought about by microscopic processes, be it errors in naturally-occurring processes or external microscopic organisms bringing about this change. That’s it. That’s essentially the Western Medicine model of disease. When we approach illness, we are trying to restore the body’s function to its default. We give medications or we perform surgery to try to restore this balance somehow. We may also advise modifications in diet, physical activities, exposure to the external environment, etc. The “treatments” we recommend are based on scientific evidence that they have some effect on illness.
I am comfortable with the model of medicine I have been trained in. I am comfortable with the level of scientific evidence it demands. Because I’m both comfortable in this system and believe in the scientific method and the stringency demanded of the “treatments” in Western Medicine, I find it hard to accept other models of medicine. Is that a bad thing? That is akin to asking ‘Is it bad that I’m a Christian and not a Jew?’ No; it isn’t a bad thing. It’s what I’m comfortable with, what I know and understand, and the alternative is unknown to me. Alternative models of medicine are to me as foreign as Zoroastrianism. Because these things are largely unknown to me, I lack knowledge and exposure to them, and –importantly– I lack belief in them, it’s better that I stick to the kind of medicine and the kind of religion I know and believe.
Now, back to the point of scientific evidence. The model of medicine I practice in, Western Medicine, what I simply call medicine, has a few postulates that to me are important. For example, it demands that the positive effect of treatments be reproducible, that side-effects are minimal and predictable, that treatment is better than no treatment (and by a significant margin), and that the treatment has been tested many times over for safety. The treatments supported by other models of medicine may lack some of these stringent criteria in favour for other priorities (e.g. that it is derived from ‘natural’ products, etc.). As I said, to me (and for the majority of my patients), the level of scientific evidence that Western Medicine demands is all-important. But if others are happy with an alternative model of medicine and alternative levels of evidence that they demand of their treatment, then I can only respect that in the same way I see it as my duty to respect other people’s religious, cultural, and other beliefs.
For example, I have patients who tell me, against widely-accepted scientific evidence, that they don’t believe that smoking is bad because their relative smoked until the age of 100 and died of causes unrelated to smoking. This person requires a study of only one person who is significant to them to make their conclusions. Or they may tell me that their friend down the road told them that sunscreen causes skin cancer, and that is why they refuse to wear it. This person, again, requires only anecdotal “evidence”. Or they may tell me that blood-pressure-lowering or cholesterol-lowering drugs cause more harm than good, but the arsenic-containing but “natural” compound sold by their naturopath is the best thing for it. This person believes that a product being “natural” means it’s automatically safer and more beneficial than one that has been rigorously scientifically tested. What can I say to these people? Well, usually nothing that will change their minds if they don’t believe in the model of medicine I have been instructed in. But what I usually do is explain to them in Western Medicine and scientific terms why I believe the treatment Western Medicine suggests is appropriate, what the risks are of not treating it this way, and then ask them what else they wish to know about this particular treatment. After that, it’s up to the individual patient to make their own choices. And no, I don’t think of them as crazy for ignoring my advice :)
You know, I believe in God. I believe in the Judeo-Christian version of God and in creationism. I’m comfortable in believing these stories that if you applied the scientific level of “proof” are actually quite laughable. So how do I get around holding such preposterous beliefs and still having some sort of pride in calling myself both a Christian and a scientist? I don’t apply the same level of proof or set of rules to all my beliefs. And yet, why do I believe the Christian and not the Islamic or Mosaic or Taoist or any other version of life philosophy? A whole heap of reasons! Probably because the country I grew up in had 99% of its population listed as catholic. Probably because my family is Christian. Probably because Christianity was all around me and the stories were told to me since I was very young. I was told from very early on also that the people who lived in my house were my siblings, my mum, etc. and I believed it. Even now I do not see the need to demand DNA-evidence to “prove” the story that these people are related to me. Similarly, I was told stories about God and Jesus and prophets, etc., and I am happy still to believe them. But what has all this got to do with my initial story about the lady who wanted to see the naturopath?
I’ve been trained in Western Medicine. I have a system in my mind with which I approach illness and human functioning. Briefly, I studied anatomy and physiology and pathophysiology so I believe 1) The body has these organ systems working together to make the body function in the environment, 2) The body is trying to stay “alive” and function properly as it’s default, 3) When the body is failing at functioning, it is because of an illness, 5) Illness is brought about by microscopic processes, be it errors in naturally-occurring processes or external microscopic organisms bringing about this change. That’s it. That’s essentially the Western Medicine model of disease. When we approach illness, we are trying to restore the body’s function to its default. We give medications or we perform surgery to try to restore this balance somehow. We may also advise modifications in diet, physical activities, exposure to the external environment, etc. The “treatments” we recommend are based on scientific evidence that they have some effect on illness.
I am comfortable with the model of medicine I have been trained in. I am comfortable with the level of scientific evidence it demands. Because I’m both comfortable in this system and believe in the scientific method and the stringency demanded of the “treatments” in Western Medicine, I find it hard to accept other models of medicine. Is that a bad thing? That is akin to asking ‘Is it bad that I’m a Christian and not a Jew?’ No; it isn’t a bad thing. It’s what I’m comfortable with, what I know and understand, and the alternative is unknown to me. Alternative models of medicine are to me as foreign as Zoroastrianism. Because these things are largely unknown to me, I lack knowledge and exposure to them, and –importantly– I lack belief in them, it’s better that I stick to the kind of medicine and the kind of religion I know and believe.
Now, back to the point of scientific evidence. The model of medicine I practice in, Western Medicine, what I simply call medicine, has a few postulates that to me are important. For example, it demands that the positive effect of treatments be reproducible, that side-effects are minimal and predictable, that treatment is better than no treatment (and by a significant margin), and that the treatment has been tested many times over for safety. The treatments supported by other models of medicine may lack some of these stringent criteria in favour for other priorities (e.g. that it is derived from ‘natural’ products, etc.). As I said, to me (and for the majority of my patients), the level of scientific evidence that Western Medicine demands is all-important. But if others are happy with an alternative model of medicine and alternative levels of evidence that they demand of their treatment, then I can only respect that in the same way I see it as my duty to respect other people’s religious, cultural, and other beliefs.
For example, I have patients who tell me, against widely-accepted scientific evidence, that they don’t believe that smoking is bad because their relative smoked until the age of 100 and died of causes unrelated to smoking. This person requires a study of only one person who is significant to them to make their conclusions. Or they may tell me that their friend down the road told them that sunscreen causes skin cancer, and that is why they refuse to wear it. This person, again, requires only anecdotal “evidence”. Or they may tell me that blood-pressure-lowering or cholesterol-lowering drugs cause more harm than good, but the arsenic-containing but “natural” compound sold by their naturopath is the best thing for it. This person believes that a product being “natural” means it’s automatically safer and more beneficial than one that has been rigorously scientifically tested. What can I say to these people? Well, usually nothing that will change their minds if they don’t believe in the model of medicine I have been instructed in. But what I usually do is explain to them in Western Medicine and scientific terms why I believe the treatment Western Medicine suggests is appropriate, what the risks are of not treating it this way, and then ask them what else they wish to know about this particular treatment. After that, it’s up to the individual patient to make their own choices. And no, I don’t think of them as crazy for ignoring my advice :)
Labels:
alternative medicine,
chinese medicine,
medication,
medicine,
natural medicine,
naturopathy,
religion
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




