Monday, June 25, 2012

On what we teach about sex


A few incidents in the last few years of work have made me wonder about the different ways and the different things that parents educate their children about sex. There’s the biological stuff, which is what parents for some reason think is most confronting, but that every single generation in every single country and in fact every sexually-reproducing species since the beginning of animal existence has figured out quite easily. A parent could get away with not ever mentioning to their offspring how babies are made, where they come out of, and the logistics of what sexual intercourse entails, and they’d pick it up anyway. I mean, in most cultures before our grandparents generation such things weren’t discussed by parents with their children – and yet people still had sex and had children, etc. It’s even less of a concern in modern days where there’s television and other media, there’s schools purposely teaching this stuff, and there’s other people (e.g. peers, relatives, health professionals, etc.) who will readily discuss the biology of sex with anyone. So it’s not what we teach children about the physiology of sex that concerns me, but that other stuff we tend to forget about sometimes, the psychosocial aspects of sex in a person’s life.

To go back again to the “olden” days now. Religion used to be a big part in a greater proportion of people’s lives ‘back in the olden days’. That’s a fact, that less people these days than, say, 100 years ago had a religious affiliation, whether that be because they elected to or were expected to by state mandates. In most religions, sex has/had a spiritual connotation and there were rules and consequences described around it. If you had sex before a marriage was confirmed, with someone outside of that marriage agreement, etc. you had “sinned” and would incur a punishment for it. Now, the punishment would be either or both imposed upon you by the church (e.g. been disassociated from the congregation) or by God (e.g. you were lead to believe that God would punish you by disapproval or loss of a post-life privilege, dependant on what the religious creed was). For the non-religious (and of course still applied to the religious) in ‘the olden days’, there was this thing about reputation and social norms.  Of course, social norms and expectations (as does religion) still exist, but modern Western culture places less of an emphasis on it, and more on being your own individual. So our parents and grandparents generation placed greater emphasis on whether others thought or knew that you had been engaging in something as disreputable as having sex with someone you weren’t married to. Sex was a shameful thing. Even for those that were married, it was not a proper thing to discuss or make jokes about or depict in media or entertainment, etc. So, back in the day a parent who educated a child about the psychosocial aspects of sex (the physiology been much too embarrassing to discuss outside of biology classes or by scientists), all you had to do is tell the child not to have sex because they’d either go to hell and die or that the whole town would call them a slut and their life would be miserable.

What are we teaching our children now about sex? Everyone knows about the physiology of sex, even very young children, and parents and their children will share very explicit details about sex. What’s wrong with that? Nothing – except that sex to human beings isn’t just about the biology of it. There’s nothing wrong with having all this knowledge about sex at all! But I’m beginning to believe that we’ve taken too much comfort in only sharing the easy stuff about sex, the stuff every child will eventually figure out even if their parent never tells them about, and have left our children with the hard stuff to figure out on their own.

In my job I’ve met many teenagers having absolutely never considered some of the other consequences of sex, let alone how to deal with them. We teach our children about sex, what it entails, that there’s the possibility of pregnancy and infections, to use condoms to prevent infections, and to use contraception to avoid pregnancy. But where children are missing out on instruction is about romantic relationships, who to have sex with, why or why not to have sex, how is sex related to love, should sex bear any relationship to love at all? These are all questions that increasingly younger people are having to charge through on their own. And I’d like to share with you some examples of questions that I have witnessed some very anxious teenagers try to deal with on their own too:
  • How do I tell my parents I’m pregnant? Do they need to know?
  • How do I tell my ex-boyfriend that I’m pregnant? Should I tell him?
  • Should I tell my parents or my ex-partner/s that I have and STD? How can I tell them?
  • Why did I get an STD when I was with a person I loved?
  • Should I quit school because the other students won’t stop bullying me about being pregnant in high school?
  • Is it ok to be sad about having a miscarriage even though no one else knew I was pregnant?
  • What do I do now that I’m pregnant and my parents don’t want me to be and I still haven’t formed a concept on how I feel about abortion?
  • How do I tell my girlfriend without hurting her feelings that I think she has a problem ‘down below’ because those warts don’t look normal?
  • How can I get an STD when I use a condom all the time except with my regular girlfriend and she isn’t with anyone other than me?
  • Is sex always meant to be painful or is it just because I don’t actually want it when it happens?
  • Is it normal not to have had sex yet at my age? Does that mean I am lacking something or am sick?

Can a parent or anything in life prepare you to answer those questions? I don’t know. But it certainly would break your heart to have first considered questions like these when they apply directly to you and the situation you find yourself in. I say, good on us for talking to our children openly about sex and the need for safe sex practices and why they’re important, but it’s now time to do the real hard work: prepare our children to think of the consequences if they do find themselves in situations where the safe sex has simply failed. Encourage the young person to think of their own opinions about abortion, about social discrimination against teen parents, about sexually transmitted infections, about the link between love, sex, and relationships, about the effect on career development and parenthood, etc. We don’t need to mandate our kids to the effect of “don’t have sex or you’ll die”, but we could encourage them to ask themselves “could I deal with any of the consequences of sex? If not, then do I need to delay sex for now?” And do this not because the child will go to hell or society will ostracize him, but because he is an independent being worthy of not suffering the negative consequences of sex.

Sunday, June 10, 2012

On prescription drug abusers


Every now and again all doctors will come across a person who wants to access prescription medications for the wrong reasons. Some people will want them to feed their own personal addictions, and others will resell them for a profit on the streets. Personally, I am never one to judge people for their weakness or for their lifestyle choices, yet this scenario bothers most doctors for a variety of reasons. It bothers me because the false stories these people tell will make me second guess and misjudge the person who tells the same story but it is true and they have a real need for these medications. And, yes, it is also frustrating to have to deal with patients who are lying to you or who abuse your trust or become aggressive/threatening when you challenge them or deny them what they want when all you’re trying to do is get on with your daily job.

There are some government systems in place to help doctors identify people who abuse prescription drugs, but unfortunately they have big limitations. The biggest reason they probably don’t work is that a doctor has to first decide to enquire with them about a specific patient. Now, the patient who is a prescription drug abuser usually knows how not to arouse suspicion from doctors – therefore the doctor never decides to check their background! In medical school they taught us some basic things that should arouse our suspicion that a patient may be a drug abuser, but most drug abusers have figured these out and found ways to deal with us to make us believe they aren’t one of those people we learnt about all those years ago. For example, some of the things we were taught are that drug abusers tend to:
  •          book the last appointment of the day (no, not anymore. If anything, they tend to be morning people)
  •          ask for specific medication (they know how to calculate equivalent doses of whatever you give them if it’s from the same drug class. They also know to ask for an NSAID and paracetamol along with their opiates and benzos)
  •          can’t back up their stories with clinical data (they have scars to prove the “surgery”, the medical report from the hospital, the clinical signs on examination, the old packets of the medication they have been prescribed, the imaging report, the name of the interstate specialist who looks after their condition but is unfortunately unavailable right now, etc.)
  •          they become angry if you question them about drug abuse (“Oh no, doctor, not me. You can even call my specialist – oh wait, he’s not there today”…)
  •          refuse referral or liason with other clinicians (you have to admire these guys’ confidence in their lies. I once was  informed by a hospital oncology department that I was the 15th GP that week that had referred a patient for urgent review– a patient who did not actually have the metastatic cancer the CT report he provided from his interstate doctor, a doctor who knew nothing of the patient either)
Most doctors agree that a solution to the problem of prescribing to patients who abuse prescription medications is to have a real-time system of prescribing where the doctor is alerted to how many times a drug of abuse has already been prescribed to a patient. Would it work? Maybe, or maybe not. I hope it does if it's ever introduced.

To be honest, what bothers me most about the issue of prescription drug abusers is not that I was once duped by an amputee who claimed to be a war veteran but who had in fact lost a limb from intravenous drug use related disease (and not a war injury as he claimed) and I gave a script for opiates to. But that that experience made me doubt the next amputee war veteran I saw who had lost his limb through war injury and had severe phantom limb pain for which his pain specialist had prescribed a whole concoction of drugs, including opiates. Had his specialist not been available and his story backed up, I may well have let him go without receiving the proper medical care he deserved. That is my greatest fear regarding this: not that I feed a junkie’s addiction, but that I commit an injustice to a real and deserving patient.

Sunday, June 3, 2012

On the jobs we do


A quote often attributed to Walt Disney is to “find a job that you like so much that you’d do it without compensation; then do it so well that people will pay you to continue”. Recently, a few people have asked me for advice (and also simply discussion) on career choice. Until not long ago, I believed that career choice should be based on one thing only: passion. I have now come to consider that there are many ways to live a life – and not all are based on career choice. So instead of just discussing jobs today, I want to discuss satisfaction and success in life.

What is a successful life? Well, in the world we live in and the story the media feeds us success is measured in dollar value, in popularity, and in gaining the admiration of others. We think of successful people as entertainment performers, businesspeople with lots of wealth, and sportspeople who win competitions. But what really is success? In the simplest sense of the word, success is about having a goal and achieving it. A successful person, therefore, is someone who attains a goal they set about to achieve. In this is sense it is superfluous for anyone of us to call someone else successful unless we know what their goals and passions in life truly are.

One thing is deciding on a career choice, and quite another is having a fulfilling and successful life. Career choice is easy; the only thing hard about it is deciding what importance you place on a job in your life. To summarise I put it this way, there are three types of people in the workplace: You are either the kind of person where 1) Your job pays your bills so that you can engage in the things that bring you true fulfilment, 2) Your career is what brings you fulfilment and the rest is “merely living”, or 3) You are of that tiny minority that generate both an income and derive true pleasure from your job. Neither of these modes of thinking about your job are “good” or “bad”, they’re just the decisions we make. The choice doesn’t matter, but what will make you a miserable person is being one of these three people, but working a job out of sync with what your beliefs are.

Living to work
The first kind of way to live a life is to live for your work. What I mean by this is that your job is what gives your life meaning and a sense of fulfilment. Of course, life isn’t just about jobs and careers but there is nothing wrong with having your job as the priority in your life. Not all of us can and I couldn’t and wouldn’t want to, but that is not to say that this is a bad thing.

I have read a fair bit about Temple Grandin, a highly intelligent and proficient woman with autism. She dedicates her time to helping animals, designing animal-friendly farm equipment, and the study of many scientific subjects. Someone once asked her if now that she has all these university degrees, money from her businesses, does she not want for more in her life. Does she not want love, a husband, children? No; she says she didn’t. She feels complete and fulfilled. Her life is successful – and there is nothing wrong with that! I have incredible respect for Temple Grandin.

Working to live
You meet the most wonderfully creative people working jobs waiting tables and selling you movie tickets and cleaning your floors and dishes. To most people these are “menial” jobs, or money jobs. Rarely do people desire an entire career or lifetime doing these jobs, but the truth is that they do put food on the table and pay the rent, etc. Now, don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying everyone who works these jobs are secretly creative geniuses by night or anything like that. But having some money around is helpful to anyone, particularly if you are trying to also be creative in your own time and at your own pace without the pressure to make a living from your creative or humanitarian or whatever other endeavours. The downside to having a “hobby” is that unfortunately many so-called unskilled jobs come with menial wages and the struggle to survive on this can come to kill the most well-intentioned creativity. The instinct to eat is almost always greater than the instinct to express yourself or help others. And yet it’s not always about creative expression.
 
Many times I have craved in difficult times a job that didn’t require me to think about it after I leave my jobsite, that people’s health/life weren’t dependent on my decisions when I felt unsure, or that I could afford more time spent at home. Spending less time and relative effort on the thing that only brings you income has the advantage to allow you to build the wealth that may be of more value to you: true human warmth, compassion, caring, and the sense of belonging to a family where every member is crucial and appreciated. Personally, family IS of great value to me. Working to live is about working a job for an income so that you can afford (cognitively and emotionally too, not just financially) to do the things that bring you true fulfilment.

Working with passion
The quote I mentioned at the start is essentially about getting paid to fulfil your passions, and that is the last scenario I want to consider. At first you may think that I have already spoken about this when I discussed living to work, but this a bit different. I often meet people who tell me “I wish I could have been a …” and no matter what their age I always ask them why they’re not. The responses I can tell you are almost always excuses and not reasons.

There is a minority of people who won’t make excuses, and they become the people who reach the summit of their chosen careers. In any field of industry (but particularly in sports, performance arts, and business), the general trend is for there to be many people in the lower ranks of industry trying to make it to the top - and there are just very few spots at the top. It is, of course, very easy to become discouraged by the numbers, the statistics, and the probabilities. And we’re very good at thinking of reasons why we can’t succeed and imagining stories other than the truth of why others did/do succeed. The actual truth, though, is that there are no easy ways to the top – and accepting that challenge because of a burning desire to reach that top is what will give you the strength to overlook the statistics and probabilities. Isn’t that a foolish thing to do, though? I mean, what if you die and you have never reached that summit you desired so much? Isn’t your whole life a failure then? I pondered this once, actually (and, yes, probably because I was looking for a reason to give up), and it was just at the time I watched a news report on some military officers who died in battle. I realised that the news reports kept referring to them as war heroes, brave people who had made the ultimate sacrifice for something they believed in. Of course, in military terms the goal is to win the battle – and if you die trying you’re not considered a loser, but a hero. Yes, a hero, a successful person! Do you see what I’m getting at?...

But the damn statistics loom over your head always like a horoscope. Very very few people make it to the summit of their chosen career field – but those who do didn’t get there by accident or just by wishing it so. In medicine I’ve had colleagues tell me about the disheartening statistics: they want to be a specialist in this field but there’s only so very few people who get this job in Australia. My answer to them is always the same too: “yes, and why can’t that person be you?”. Why? Oh, yes, we are all very good at thinking of reasons why others are successful and we never will be. Others slept with the boss, probably; they are smarter than us; they have a postgraduate qualification we don’t have; their parents know people who know people, etc. I guarantee you that if you meet the people who are at the top of their field of industry and actually ask them how they got there, few will tell you that it was because they were “just lucky”. No, they will tell you of their struggle, their sacrifices, and their previous setbacks. What I’m saying is that if you are truly in your heart passionate about a specific career, then what you need to focus on is being the one in the statistic, and forget about whether it is out of a hundred, a thousand, a million, or however many billions.

Living with passion
So far I have only spoken about work, but for most people work is only one important aspect of living, not the most important. And I think the whole question of “what career is best for me?” is better rephrased into the key question “what do I want a career to give me?” There are many ways to live a life and many different types of jobs out there, but only a person can decide for themselves what role a job plays in their life with regards to satisfaction, overall life goals, etc.

For the greatest majority of people our goal in life is to be happy and not to be miserable. If you have a passion in life, a passion without which your life will seem miserable to you, then you have an overwhelming desire to fulfil this one task. If that is you, then you (have to) become the person who won’t take no for an answer. You become the kind of person that doesn’t believe in failure only as-yet-unsuccessful attempts. You have to become resilient and keep trying until you can attain the “job” of your dreams. And note that by “job” I mean any task in life that you are passionate about; could be a paid job, could be to be a mother, could be to create something, it could be anything at all. But I can tell you that living with passion is such an empowering and enriching way to think of life. You could die trying to succeed and know that you’ve already succeeded!

Monday, May 21, 2012

On how relationships are like Satan


Today I want to talk about Satan. Well, on how Satan reminds me so much about relationships. It’ll come as no surprise that my spiritual teachings have been mostly from the Judaeo-Christian faith, so it’s understandable that I use this analogy. To the uninitiated, the story of Satan is like this: God (the creator of absolutely everything) made this really powerful angel, who later came to be called Satan. He gave him the best of everything and was his favourite son. God said to him that the only person above him was God himself, and so he had to obey and worship God same as the other spiritual creatures God had made. It was a pretty sweet deal for Satan to be the favourite son of God… But then this Satan dude got to thinking ‘hey, why should I have to obey?’, ‘what gives God the right to decide what is good and bad for others? that seems unfair’, and ‘why does he have to get all the worship of others? I want some worship too’, and finally ‘what will happen if someone does disobey God?’… And so he came about to answer some of his questions by some very intelligent means using the newest of God’s creations, whom God claimed were in his image and likeness: humans.

Thinking beyond what is good for you
You know when you first meet someone and become attracted to them and everything they do seems right. You love their smile, what they smile about, how they interact with you and respond to you, how they think, how they behave, how they make you feel, etc.  Awww, it’s all so sweet. And you love spending time together, sharing, enjoying adventures in the present, telling tales of the past, and planning futures together. But then something happens. Maybe it’s that too much of a good thing makes our brains want to find a fault in the reality of things. Satan, our predecessor, had it all but he started to wonder, “is there even more?” Soon he started to want these (supposedly) even better things even though he’d never had them and certainly wasn’t suffering without. I mean, why does the “honeymoon” phase of relationships have to end?

Envy
There are no two equal relationships in the world and no two equal lovers in relationships. Everyone has different backgrounds and different expectations of the future. There is looking forward with desire to the future, and there is looking sideways with desire (and maybe contempt?) to others’ present. The last of these is called envy. Sometimes in relationships, even great romances, the lovers can begin to notice other people who are in love, or even other people who have loved you or whom you loved once, and begin to feel less than these others. But why? Wasn’t the relationship great to begin with? Yes, in the same way Satan already had a pretty awesome life before he decided he’d rather be like God instead. It’s one of the most absurd things on this universe to ignore what you have for the stupidity of wanting to have what others have. What often happens is the same as when you get distracted on the road when you see something “interesting”: you crash your own car for something so insignificant. Satan lost his paradise kingdom for desiring something other than what that paradise had to offer him.

Slander
Christians believe that the first lie told was the lie told to Eve by Satan disguised as a serpent. He said to her, “your God has lied to you”. That, however, was a lie. Eve ran with that lie because we human beings are incredibly good at believing lies - it’s almost as if we crave it! The hardest thing in a relationship isn’t believing a lie, no, that’s the easiest thing; the hardest thing is trusting enough to believe the truth. Losing trust, I believe, is the only thing irreparable in any relationship.

Doubt
There are so many unknowable things in this universe, the most unknowable one to us humans are other human beings’ intentions – and yet it is what we most commonly claim to know so well! There are no proofs, confessions, eyewitness accounts, promises, or alibis that can convince an untrusting mind. Satan could have killed Adam and Eve if he wanted to, he could have attempted to overthrow God’s regime, but instead he did something more subtle that had the same effect: he created doubt. Adam and Eve had all the proof in the universe that this God dude had only good intentions and he’d only ever been good to them by giving them all this really cool stuff (the earth and animals and everything to care for), but Satan made them doubt God’s intention and his word. They didn’t have proof that God was bad, but they came to doubt his “goodness”. How often in relationships do we see conflict created not by proof of wrongdoing but of doubt? We can doubt our partner’s faithfulness, their intentions for the future, the nature of their past, the intentions of their current actions... But why? Why do we do this to ourselves?  I don’t know what the answer to that is. But oh how convinced I could become that relationships are the work of the devil!
J

Sunday, April 29, 2012

On jealousy


In my experience, there are four types of people in relationships: the jealous types, the ones in denial about being jealous types, those with a good sense of self-worth, and those who aren’t really in love. I’m of the jealous type. I quite openly admit that because I know myself and I know that I have never liked my partners paying too much attention, comfort, or affection towards others, especially if that attention, comfort, and affection tends to be focused on one or a few people. Why do I get jealous? Well, the immediate reason is I want all of my partner’s attention, comfort, and affection because I am in love with them! The non-immediate reason is I wonder if all that fond interaction between my partner and someone else could eventually lead to romantic feelings between them. And of course I’m in love with my partner and I don’t want that to happen. It’s not far-fetched, either; when we are courting someone what we do is start to pay them more attention, affection, etc… So, yes, of course, they could potentially fall in love.  Anyhow, that is the reasoning of us jealous types.

The people in denial about being jealous types are usually those at the absolute extreme of jealousy! Generally, these are the people who become jealous about you even interacting with completely platonic friends and family. The problem isn’t that they’re in love with you and want you not to fall in love with others; the problem is usually that they don’t trust that you love them. I used to think that jealousy happened because of this pathological sense of possessiveness, but really it’s more about having a poor sense of self-worth. If someone pays your partner some attention (even that may come about in the normal workings of a day), or if (god forbid) your partner pays someone other than you some attention, the exuberantly jealous partner’s thoughts run to “they’re going to leave me”. But the full statement they’re saying to themselves, often subconsciously, is “they’re going to leave me because I’m not good enough or as good as anyone else”. But before you go and feel sorry for the poor person with the low self-esteem, think for a second of the partner. As the partner of someone at the extremes of jealousy what you feel is this constant statement that your love for your partner isn’t convincing them enough, that you never quite do the right thing to convince them of your love, and that your own commitment isn’t valued and is being doubted each time. Unfortunately, the jealous partner can eventually start to leave out from conversations the “I love you”, the “I’ve missed you”, the “how was your day?”. Instead they greet you with an interrogation into who you’ve spoken to and spent time with, etc. Sadly, this is how jealousy erodes relationships.

Those with a good sense of self-worth are ideal partners, then, right? Yes, when they don’t doubt your love for them and their love for you… But it’s not all about self-worth. Paulo Coelho, in his novel The Zahir, speaks of a couple of two very self-assured people. They’ve been married many years and are far from what you’d describe as jealous. One day, suddenly, the woman leaves the man. He had no idea of there being any trouble in the relationship or the woman being unhappy or wanting to leave him. In fact, it turns out, he knew very little about his wife. There’s a thin line between trying not to come across as jealous and simply not caring. When you take no interest in your partner’s life, you risk not being a part of it.

Do I have a point with this discussion? I guess I’m just trying to make a point of being aware of the messages we put out in relationships, of being self-aware of our relationship style, and of reflecting on whether the way we interact is putting across the right message to our partners.

Sunday, April 22, 2012

On birthing - part 2


I once met an obstetrician who told me “a healthy baby lives, a sick baby dies”. That was his approach to that time around the birth of a child and also to prenatal care. At the time, I was quite shocked! I thought, then what is the point of medical advances in technology, of medical research, and basically of “medicine” in general? We have studied disease, pathophysiology, human anatomy, microbiology, biotechnology, and devised all sorts of theories and methods to try to keep people alive and healthy. What’s the point of medicine if not that? Well, the obstetrician’s theory was that we may have studied too much, devised too many new things, and medicalised too many things that would (and should, apparently) be just thought of as part of human life: things like childbirth and pregnancy.

I admit that it does concern me when you consider the massive amounts of money spent in neonatal intensive care wards and the number of chronic health problems suffered by those born prematurely. Over the past few decades, the gestational age at with a child could be born safely and with the best chance of survival has drastically lowered. At one point in history, a child born 6 weeks before its due date had little chance of survival. Then someone decided that this should not just be accepted as fact and the chance of survival could be increased by some or another medical intervention. Gradually, newer and newer methods have been devised to support the survival of increasingly more premature (younger) babies. However, the issues has become one not just about supporting a premature baby to survive its first few months of life, but these babies go on to become infants, adolescents, and even adults. The earlier than anticipated a child is born, the greater his chance of dying. The medical efforts needed to keep these babies alive costs a lot of money. Then after ensuring the baby will survive into infanthood, the fact is the younger that child was born, the greater the risk that he will suffer chronic, sometimes lifelong, health problems. The management of chronic health problems of children and adults again costs a fortune. The life of a person who is prematurely-born is, therefore, very draining of resources, economically speaking.

Would it be better if we made health care decisions based solely on economics? Or would it be better if we based them based solely on “nature”, and ‘let nature take its course’ when a woman goes into labour prematurely? Why do we find it so repulsive to accept that “a healthy baby lives, a sick baby dies”? The truth is that the majority of us human beings couldn’t sleep at night if we made decisions like this. If you ask the women who have given birth to premature babies, even extremely premature ones, if the life-saving efforts to keep their children alive into adulthood were worth it (even if that life went on to be marked by chronic illness), do you know what almost all of them would say? They’d say “Yes, of course it was worth it!” And that is because you are talking about a person to whom they have a profoundly close connection, and also because it is a small “innocent” child, apparently deserving of all our best intentions, efforts, love, money, protection, etc. etc. It is also another human being, a person. You could summarise it by saying that we are humane towards other human beings; we are human. That is why we act so many times against logic, against “nature”, against economic viability, and against the greater majority’s good.

For the majority of persons, our instinct is to promote the survival of ourselves and other people; but when it comes to fetuses, there has always been a discussion into whether or when they can be considered a “person”. Now, I’m not about to go into a philosophical, theological, or bioethical discussion about abortion because frankly I think that is a discussion an individual can only have with themselves and come to their own conclusions; I only care to discuss an interesting scenario that was recently raised. Some Australian philosophers made an argument that newborn children are no different to fetuses because they do not understand or yet know what life is, let alone appreciate it. They don’t know what it is to be human, they don’t identify themselves as persons, therefore, they are not persons with the usual “standard” human rights, including a right to be alive. In theory at least, then, you could extend the arguments raised about fetal abortion to “post-natal abortions”, i.e. a newborn child being considered no different to a fetus. If is right or wrong to carry out a procedure to procure the destruction of a fetus with no known congenital defect, so it should be right or wrong to destroy a full-term newly born healthy child... Before I digress, let me just ask if a child has rights? If so, when do those rights come into effect?

Now, I wanted to discuss birthing and not actually “abortion”. Ms. Janet Fraser, whom I spoke about earlier, claims to have incorporated into the coroner’s investigation into her daughter’s death, a stance to defend “women’s rights”. Specifically, she wants acknowledgement of a right of a woman to decide the birthing method of her unborn child, independent from any right owed to the child (or potential child). That’s ok, right? Legally, a cognitively competent person has a right to make decisions over her own body and any intervention to it, medically or otherwise. That legal right overrides the fact of whether an intervention is actually good for you or not. For example, I can refuse to have any surgery being performed upon me, even if that surgery can save my life and without it I will undoubtedly and precipitously die. But not just life-saving surgery, I have a legal right to refuse any medical intervention at all… What about epidural anesthesia at the time of birthing, is it ok to refuse that? What about antenatal care? I mean, pregnancy is not illness, so why should a person be forced to see a medical person, right?.. And what about fetal monitoring? No woman in labour particularly wants to be touched by anyone else. What about wanting to deliver a child traditionally at home and not in a modern hospital, particularly if you are scared of hospitals? And what about assisted delivery, I mean that is rarely to help the woman, is it? What about refusing a caesarian section, that’s a type of surgery so why should a person not have a right to refuse that?...

Why are these questions interesting? Because we accept that a person has a right to make decisions about their own body and their healthcare, but we are also aware that the decisions of this person affect another human being (even if we don’t consider them an independent person yet). Though we are unsure whether this “person” or “potential person” is owed any rights, we have this niggling little feeling that they deserve at least a chance or some consideration in the whole argument. What is the answer? Should a hierarchy be legally set up to nominate whose rights are or whose life is more important at the time of birthing? I don't claim to know what the right answer is, but unfortunately in the world we live in, people tend to be motivated more by laws and potential for punishment (or material reward) than the things that moved us in the past. I guess we can’t expect all people to reason that they will sacrifice something, anything, to ensure the safety and health of their child as a priority to their own personal preferences.

(I will not be donating any of my money to Ms. Fraser’s ‘fight for the rights of all women’, mostly because I appreciate and encourage more people [and not just women] to consider at least in some situations, that other fellow human’s lives are at least as worthy as their lifestyle preferences.)

Sunday, April 15, 2012

On birthing - part 1

I recently read a blog post by Janet Fraser where she asked for donations to help fund a legal battle she’s involved in. There is an ongoing coroner’s inquest into the death of her baby so it’s hard to comment on what still has a large number of unknown facts. Briefly, the allegations are that around late 2008, Janet Fraser became pregnant with her third child and decided that her child would be birthed at home without the involvement of any medical or nursing staff. There were apparently no medical antenatal checks during her pregnancy. In March 2009, she went into labour and as she and her partner had planned, they prepared for the birth of their child in their home. At the end of the labour, she delivered a full-term baby that was dead. Resuscitation attempts were made by the child’s father, and then an ambulance was called to take the child to hospital. The baby was not able to be resuscitated. Janet Fraser is not on trial for murder of a child; she is involved in a legal fight to establish her (and, as she claims, all “women’s”) rights to be able to opt to give birth at home, unassisted by medical staff.

Janet Fraser has delivered 3 children, the first of which was born in hospital. In 2003, Ms. Fraser was admitted to hospital for delivery of her first child. The whole interaction of this visit was experienced as a very negative, indeed “traumatic”, experience for her. The physical (aka vaginal) examination was unpleasant, the medical and nursing staff made medical and nursing decisions (apparently for and about her and not in conjunction with her), and her right to a vaginal delivery was denied. A caesarean section was performed for delivery of this child, as deemed medically necessary for either mother and/or child. Ms. Fraser felt that this “medical need” should have been no reason to overlook her right to make health care decisions (i.e. whether to have surgery or not), and a result of this she felt personally violated by the hospital system when the caesarean section was performed on her. This hospital birthing experience came to be interpreted by her as akin to rape. She never wanted to experience this ever again.

For delivery of her second child in 2006, Ms. Fraser wanted to avoid all possibility of having a caesarean section performed upon her (presumably against her will) and so decided to deliver this child at home. She eventually went into labour and this lasted 50 hours. After the birth of the child, she suffered a severe haemorrhage and was taken to hospital. Upon admission to hospital, she reported to hospital staff that she had only being in labour 3 hours so as to avoid potential reporting to policing authorities for child neglect or abuse (from willingly submitting the child to a prolonged labour). I wonder if she herself considered that this whole thing could be called child neglect or abuse had the possibility of prosecution not been raised…

Delivery of her third child in 2009 was attempted in the same way that of the second child was, at home. I guess Ms. Fraser considered that the risk of having another difficult birth after 2 previously difficult births did not warrant the greater medical care that may be offered in hospital. Everyone takes risks in life, right? There is always the chance that mum and/or baby could die during birth, regardless of where it takes place. There was always also the chance that Ms. Fraser could have delivered her third child healthily and so smoothly at her home that none of us would ever have heard of her. She must have weighed up those possibilities, the consequences of their potential outcomes, and then made the decision to deliver her child at home. The outcome was a dead baby; the consequence is that that outcome is final.